Document

transcript · Board meeting video

November 16, 2026 — Meeting Transcript

Meeting video
Chapters
Full transcript

Speaker labels are inferred from the recording; proper names are corrected against the public record. How this works ↗

Speaker 1

Good evening and welcome to the Plain Commission ARB for November 16th. If you have any electronic gadgets, please silence them at this point.

Speaker 2

Ryan? Steve Lichtenfeld? Here. Helen DiFate?

Ryan? Steve Lichtenfeld? Here. Helen DeFayette?

Speaker 3

Here.

Speaker 2

Jim Arsenault? Here. Chris Brennan? Here. Claire Queskin?

Speaker 3

Here.

Speaker 2

Jeff Morrisey? Here. Susan Buse?

Jeff Morsey? Here. Susan Buse?

Speaker 3

Here.

Speaker 1

We have minutes from the previous meeting on November 2nd. Are there any changes? Seeing none, do we have a motion?

Speaker 4

I move to approve as submitted.

Speaker 1

Second. All in favor? Aye. Okay. We'll go on. This is the time for our open forum. if anyone has a comment, question about anything not on the agenda for tonight, and hopefully you would have signed up on a sheet outside, raise your hand. No? Okay. We will move on to new business. The first item is 59 Arundel Place. I believe the Implicants are here, but we'll start with the staff report.

Speaker 2

All right, so the subject property is located on the north side of a frontal place between University Lane and Demund Avenue. The site is zoned R2 and is developed with a two-story single family house, detached garage, and is in the Hillcrest subdivision. The proposed scope includes the following, demolition of the existing garage, front porch, front walkway, and rear patio, installation of new windows and siding on the existing sunroom, construction of a new front pathway, front porch, from portico, rear yard patio, rear yard walkways, detached garage, a new iron fencing, and various interior renovations. The proposed garage would not meet the facade material requirements found in the architecture review guidelines. The garage exterior would comprise gray LP smart side, which is a secondary material. Brick is the most prominent material on the surrounding accessory structures. However, greater use of secondary materials is common. Staff are of the opinion that some brick should be incorporated, but the greater use of siding would align with the design of many surrounding garages. Staff are of the opinion that the remainder of the improvements would have a minimal visual impact and are compatible with the surrounding area. Staff recommend approval with the following conditions. One, bricks shall comprise at least 25% of each facade of the garage. And then two, signed and sealed plans shall be provided with the building permit submission.

Speaker 1

Okay, thank you. The applicant, come on up, introduce yourself, add anything you would like.

Speaker 5

I'm Darrell LaBriere with DL Design Architectural Firm. And?

Speaker 6

I'm Julie Nelson, Julie Nelson Interiors, the designer on the house.

Speaker 5

So we have a two-story residence. And pretty much what Ryan said, we're taking apart the front portico just a little bit and improving that. There will be a new front porch and new walks soon. And we are redoing the sunroom a little bit because it is in need of repair. And we're kind of upgrading windows and the exterior materials and all that at the same time. And then there's some remodel on the inside, the kitchen and some bathrooms. And then, of course, the detached garage, the old garage had to go. And we proposed to build a new one. This time, it will be entered off of the alley instead of the backyard.

Speaker 1

Anything else?

Speaker 6

In the back, we also will have a continuum. In the front, we're going to have pavers going up the sidewalk in a herringbone pattern and very much in keeping with the survival aesthetic. in the back we're going to have a combination of bull-nosed aggregate that will be complementary to the all the brick on the house as well as the papers in the front um so it will be landscaped and

Speaker 1

Well, I did walk around the house, both on the street side and the alley side. And I think it'll work out beautifully once you get the old garage out of there. It really needs it. And I noticed that the sunroom is all boarded up. So the windows are already taken out. Is that

Speaker 6

correct? At this point, they're just everything's boarded up. The windows are still there. I was just there this morning. but we do plan to have windows that are higher.

Speaker 5

All the present windows in Sunroom are the old aluminum, huge windows with aluminum frames. Those are all being replaced with newer windows, more fitting sizings.

Speaker 1

Well, I think the plans look very good. The question why we're here tonight is about the brick on the garage. And you've read and heard everything. Our staff is recommending at least 25% of each facade be brick. When I walked up and down the alley, the majority of the garages are brick. There are a few that are siding. There are a couple that are a combination of brick and siding. So I certainly agree with the staff report and suggestion. So what I'd like is everyone else to have their say, and then we'll go from there. Okay, Lynn?

Speaker 4

I, too, agree with the staff. When I look at it, you've gone into such detail and expense in what you're adding and the changes you're making. They're small, but they're not inexpensive details. And then I look at the garage, and there, too, you've got... a number of windows and two man doors, but the garage doesn't look like it belongs to the house. It looks like I ran out of budget and I can't do brick. So I would agree with the staff and I would suggest looking at the sunroom where you have the brick band around the bottom of the sunroom and then you're putting windows, and you're putting some of the siding, then do the same at the garage so that it looks like it belongs to the house. Yes, when you go to some of the very old homes, you will see the original brick home or stone, and then in the back, you'll see a garage. You might even find a date in the garage that is maybe 50 years after the house was built. But that's not what looks good. I mean, things are existing. We keep them. We maintain them. But you have the opportunity to do something that looks like it belongs. So I would agree with the staff.

Speaker 7

Jim? I certainly think the new garage is going to be a lot more functional than the old garage, so kudos on that. No really new thoughts. I think I agree with Helen's thoughts that if you just brought the brick up to kind of like that knee wall height that you see on the back there, I think it would be in good communication with the main building, and I think that would be enough to just kind of get you over the hump.

Speaker 1

Chris?

Speaker 8

I would agree. I don't know exactly why 25% is justified instead of 75%, but it's a step in the right direction, and I think it works well with the sunroom. As you said, Helen, do you have a sample of that LP SmartSide, the gray? You could set it right up there. Yeah, you're fine. So is that the gray smart side? That is the color that will be used? I

Speaker 6

mean, gray was not supposed to be on. That was never a consideration. That should have said white.

Speaker 5

It's supposed to be white.

Speaker 8

Okay. Did I see? I thought I saw gray marked.

Speaker 6

It did say gray. I saw that today.

Speaker 2

Okay. There was a visual sample that was provided to us during the application process. It was a very dark gray. It was almost black. Just to clarify, so is this the siding that's proposed on both the garage and the sunroom?

Speaker 6

Yes.

Speaker 2

Okay.

Speaker 6

Yes, and that's the only one we had a picture of at that moment to respond to that because we just wanted to show just the type that it shows the grain and it looks fairly close to a natural wood.

Speaker 8

Okay, so it'll be a white matching the sunroom as opposed to a gray adding another color in, is that correct?

Speaker 6

Exactly. Thank you for clarifying.

Speaker 8

I think that adding the brick is definitely a step in the right direction. And I understand with budget, probably doing the whole thing in brick gets pricey there. I don't know how much of the brick can be reused when you take down the one-car garage or the existing garage. I would hope that some of that can be. Are you planning on matching the new brick as much as possible with the existing brick?

Speaker 6

The new brick being.

Speaker 8

That 25%, if you were to put that around, this kind of as a banding or?

Speaker 6

We would be. And one of the reasons that we hesitated on wanting to do brick, the brick that is around the current sunroom, which we are keeping does not match the brick of the house. It's more of a monochromatic look versus the variant that you normally see in brick. So that's the reason the client was wanting, they're gonna spend a lot of time in that sunroom And we wanted to give them what they want to look out on. And they didn't want to look out. On a miniature of their house. They went to look out on something that just looked. Soft and. All white.

Speaker 8

Yeah, I'm in agreement. It needs to have some brick added to it. At least 25% on, on every elevation. For that is there. You're not planning on replacing the brick on the sunroom then. Yeah. Okay. Nothing further.

Speaker 1

Layer.

Speaker 3

I actually agree with Chris's initial statement that 75%. I also don't understand why we're holding it at 25, but again, 25 at a minimum for me.

Speaker 6

Can I state something also? Right next to us, the house, if you're looking towards the garage to the right, has no brick and it's all white, the garage. So we have something nearby that would look similar.

Speaker 1

Jeff?

Speaker 9

Thanks. Yeah, I agree with my colleagues about bringing the brick up to the base of the windows in the garage. I had a different question also. The addition replacement windows, will they be mullioned at all or are those unlike the rest of the house? They appear...

Speaker 6

They will be mullioned. They're going to be casement in the back but with mullions.

Speaker 9

okay so they'll so they'll blend with the rest of the house okay um yeah that's um that's all i had to add to what's already been said thanks susan

Speaker 10

i don't have much to add um some brick will certainly i think enhance the project and otherwise

Speaker 1

comments

Speaker 5

uh Well, if it was going to be 25%, I knew that we'd do the 25% with what you're talking about, with a little bit of a wainscot around underneath the windows. Look more like the sunroof.

Speaker 1

Okay. Let's see if there are any comments from the audience on this. Go hands up. Well, it looks like if I understand you would agree to do the 25% on all four sides. I know it'll be less on the garage door side due to the door. But if that's the case and you've obviously read the two staff recommendations, including the signed and sealed plans. Okay. Okay.

Speaker 8

Any further

Speaker 1

comments, Chris?

Speaker 8

Just one clarification, just to make sure we're not talking cross-purposes. We referred to 25% on each of the facades. You mentioned bringing the wainscoting up just up to the bottom of the windows.

Speaker 5

Well, the windows will have to be adjusted to wherever the sill

Speaker 8

lies. Okay. So the windows will be adjusted then?

Speaker 5

They have to be shorter.

Speaker 8

Okay. Does that require a new setup? Okay. Okay.

Speaker 5

Well, when we turn plans in with the seal on, we can make that change.

Speaker 1

They'll be correct at that. Any other comments? We have a motion.

Speaker 4

I move to approve as submitted with the two staff recommendations.

Speaker 1

Second. All in favor? Aye. Opposed?

Speaker 3

Aye.

Speaker 1

Did you get that, Ryan? Thank you. Thank you. Good luck with it. We will move on to the next property and that's 73 Arundel and the team is here. So we will start with the site plan review.

Speaker 11

The subject property is also located on the north side of Arundel Place between University Lane and DeMunn Avenue, also in the Hillcrest subdivision. It's in the R2 single-family dwelling zoning district, and the proposed project scope includes demolishing the existing two-story house and detached garage and constructing new replacements in their place. The R2 Zinkel family dwelling district requires at least 55% of the front yard area and 50% of the total lot to be green space. The project proposes a decrease from 61.2 to 50.26% total green space, while the use of the existing alley to access the garage will create a front yard that's 91.15% green space. The existing stormwater runoff is split between the rear yard to the alley and the front yard to the street. The proposed plan alters the existing pattern with the majority of runoff directed to the front yard or directly into the sewers. proposal would increase runoff by 0.03 cubic feet per second from 0.42 to 0.45 cfs the metropolitan sewer district has completed initial review of the proposed plans and is requiring volume reduction on site the proposed bioretention basin will be reviewed and monitored by msd um Let's see, the existing canopy coverage for landscaping is 2,096 square feet with 1,546 square feet to be removed. The plan proposes adding 3,250 square feet of canopy, which is 120 square feet more than the replacement requirement. The plan also exceeds the native species requirement with 100% native proposed. So the height, setbacks, green space ratio, and landscape plan as proposed comply with the requirements of the R2 district. The rain garden BMP is the first of its kind to be proposed here. Should MSD approve its functioning, staff are of the opinion that stormwater will be adequately managed on site. So staff are of the Oh, and staff recommend approval with the following condition that the applicant provide a copy of the MSD plan approval and associated recording and inspection requirements prior to the issuing of a building permit. And if in the event that MSD does not acquire a deed restriction, the applicant shall record one with St. Louis County and provide the proof of filing prior to the building permit.

Speaker 1

Okay, thank you.

Speaker 11

Thank you, Hobie.

Speaker 12

Scott. Good evening, city staff, Chairman Lichtenfeld, members of the Architectural Review Board. My name is Scott Mellman, and on behalf of Mellman Brothers Development, my brother Blair and I want to thank you for giving us this opportunity to make another presentation to this wonderful board and the residents that are here this evening. We are especially pleased that the homeowners can be here with us this evening as well. Their family has been part of the Clayton community for many years and currently resides on Arundel Place. They are very excited about the opportunity to build a new home just a few hours down from their longtime residence. For those of you who are not familiar with the property's history, the existing home was unfortunately struck by the tornado in May of 2025. Due to the extent of the damage, the home was deemed beyond repair and will need to be replaced. Fortunately, no one was injured and the new homeowners now have the opportunity to create the home they have always envisioned. Before turning things over to the other members of our development team, including our civil engineer and architect, I also want to emphasize that Blair and I look forward to continued communication and coordination with our neighbors. We are committed to being good neighbors throughout the entire process. Thank you again for the consideration and for allowing us to present this evening. With that, I'd like to introduce Eric Vietmeyer with Bowles Engineering.

Speaker 13

Good evening. I'm Eric Vietmeyer with Volz Engineering. We are the engineers of record for this project. As was stated, Hobie went through pretty well and kind of got everything. This is one of the probably the first time I've designed a MSD level rain garden or bioretention basin for a single home project in the city of Clayton. But we are in the river to pair watershed. So. Turns out by that locale, MSD requires a volume reduction BMP and this was really the only thing that would meet their criteria. I know it was mentioned about, you know, ensuring that MSD is still going to be approving it. They've already asked for a signed, notarized copy of their maintenance agreement. We've already paid that recording fee. Just waiting to hear back from MSD that it's been recorded and assuming I'm anticipating that to be coming back with their approval when MSD issues plan approval. The city is copied on the email notifying me and Melman Brothers of approval. If still need to provide you PDFs of that stamp plan and the recorded maintenance agreement, that is not a problem. I can just do that right out of hand as soon as I get that email just to satisfy everybody. So with the new green space requirements, there are two different runoff calculations we had to do because we still had to satisfy MSD. All new projects in the city Clayton are required to be approved by MSD just because the city of Clayton says 100 year 60 minute rain event. MSD still wants it all by their by their methods as well. So, looking at. The city formulas we have 1 raw value looking at MSD's methods. We have a different runoff value. The rain garden actually pieces both values. The rain garden provides the volume reduction that MSD is looking for. I've already responded to comments from MSD. They had no comment regarding any of the math. They agreed with everything to that point. And then I added an extra set of calculations on my cover sheet to show that the surface volume was enough to satisfy the city's requirements independently. So hopefully that's satisfactory to everybody to show that going on. I don't know if it's above and beyond or if I'm just doing the minimum, but I'm doing what I feel we needed to show just to make sure everybody was on board with it. So if anybody has any questions about the civil plan, more than happy to answer anything. We'll have questions. That's why I'm here.

Speaker 1

So, um, The drawing, the proposed drainage area map, could you go through that and highlight where the rain garden is, what it's going to do to the adjacent neighbors? Will water be flowing over the sidewalk?

Speaker 13

Water is all going either a little bit to the alley from the back of the garage. Everything else is going out to the street. The rear yard is going into some inlets. There's some inlets on the right-hand side that's all directly piped out to storm main in the street. What little surface on the left-hand side that is not getting into any inlets is all surface flowing down into the rain guard, and then the front yard is all going out to the street. This is a low spot, so nothing's going uphill to either adjoining neighbor. It sounds good.

Speaker 1

It laid out very

Speaker 13

well.

Speaker 1

Okay. Well, sometimes the 50-foot wide lots are problematic. but it sounds like you're going in the right direction. So what will we see at that rain garden when it's finished? Will it have a depression in it?

Speaker 13

There'll be a slight depression to it, but it'll also be landscapes on the interior of it. Bachelor Gardens of Cheshire Field was kind enough to help me out with the landscape portion of that. MSD wants to see a landscape plan. So I believe the last page of my plant set shows that landscape plan. That is not part of, that wasn't in this slide. Actually where? Scroll up. Here we go.

Speaker 1

Yes. Well, Eric, I do have a question then because I couldn't read this reduced plan. Will they be native plantings going in there?

Speaker 13

I'm not an arborist. I'm not a landscaper. The only thing I do know is they are on MSD's approved list of plantings for rain gardens, which I believe are native plants. Not 100%. Do not take my word for it. It's just my understanding.

Speaker 1

Okay. Well, what you're concerned with is the control of the water on the site.

Speaker 14

Correct.

Speaker 1

I think I have a fairly good feeling about where the water is going and where it's coming from. All the roof water will be

Speaker 13

Not all of the roof water is going to the rain garden. The front left quadrant will go to the rain garden, the rest are all going to be direct connect to a pipe running along the right-hand side that then is directly connected to the MSD sewer.

Speaker 1

In the street?

Speaker 13

Yes. Okay.

Speaker 1

Okay. Ellen?

Speaker 4

You've answered my questions, so I don't have anything further. All right.

Speaker 7

Jim? Yeah, I don't have any issues. I think, uh, I think right off the bat, even if we don't get into the rain garden with so much of the runoff just directly connecting to the sewer, I don't think even if there was much of a slope that it would affect either property too much. Um, I am excited to see the rain garden go in and, uh, and see how that turns out. Um, especially kind of it being the first of its kind in this area. And, uh, uh, I'm looking forward to driving over to the site once that gets, I think we're a while away, but

Speaker 13

it'll be the last thing that gets built. But, you know, it's with Scott and Blair running the helm on this one and Bastion Gardens doing the landscape plan for it. I'm sure it's going to look absolutely beautiful.

Speaker 7

Yes, and also the staff report does say the plan also exceeds the native species requirement with 100% native species proposed. So I think you're not an arborist, but I think you're good there.

Speaker 13

I'll pass along the kudos to Baxter Gardens.

Speaker 7

No more questions for me. Thank you. Chris?

Speaker 8

I'm really only curious about one thing. You said that there was a maintenance agreement with MSD for this rainwater basin, retention basin? Yes. So does this mean that MSD actually maintains this one?

Speaker 13

MSD does not maintain it, but MSD governs the maintenance.

Speaker 8

Okay.

Speaker 13

I actually have a copy if you'd like to take a look. It's standard boilerplate for MSD. Any project that gets a rain garden or any other – Volume reduction, water quality, BMP gets the same maintenance agreement. There is an operation and maintenance manual that I have to put together, typically a lot of boilerplate, but it's instructions for the end homeowner on how to maintain it, how to keep it functioning, what their responsibilities are.

Speaker 8

So the onus will be on the owners to keep that area maintained. And if it clogs up all of that, okay.

Speaker 14

Yes. I

Speaker 8

think it's cool. I'm looking forward to seeing that a rain garden as well. So thank

Speaker 1

you.

Speaker 3

Nothing further. Thanks.

Speaker 9

Sorry. I had to jump out for a second. I'm imagining this has already been discussed, but during the most extreme weather event, how much water will gather in the bioretention?

Speaker 13

Well, for a 100-year rain event, MSD makes me calculate all this. Water gets, where's that page? Well, actually for the standard, their design standard, water gets to be about six inches deep. For a 100-year, I would anticipate the water getting to be probably eight or nine inches deep. For

Speaker 9

what sort of surface area?

Speaker 13

For about less than 55 square feet.

Speaker 9

Okay. And then that will percolate out in about how long?

Speaker 13

There's, well, MSD's standard is about two days for the planting media. There's a special soil mix that's under the surface that promotes the porosity and infiltration to help get all that water into the ground. What cannot get in, there are drains and overflows that if there's two 15-year rain events back to back, it overflows into a central structure and then that's piped directly into the storm sewer.

Speaker 9

Okay, okay. Will that gathering of water be, wasn't... familiar, totally familiar with the landscape plan. Will it all be quote unquote hidden from view from the street or not?

Speaker 13

With all the plantings? Should be. Okay.

Speaker 9

And just a clarification from staff, have we ever had a BMP of this sort in the front yard?

Speaker 15

Not that I'm aware of. Yes, there is a rain garden on It's in High Point, just off of DeMunn. When you take the curb on Alamo, there is a rain garden in the front yard there that was constructed when they did a garage addition.

Speaker 13

Okay. I did think about putting it in the backyard, but that's usable play space for children. And to put this in that backyard, you can't use the backyard

Speaker 9

then. Yeah, yeah. Because I wish the rendering that was submitted – we had a conversation in the last meeting about how much of a reality rendering should – what the bioretention soil would look like in front of the house. It kind of gives a kind of a pristine view of what's going on. So, I mean, I have personally some concerns about this, but not from a civil standpoint, but just from an aesthetic standpoint for if I was a neighbor, for instance, in that area. Yeah.

Speaker 13

A good

Speaker 9

thing

Speaker 13

is, is there's no mosquitoes because the flowers and the plants attract the birds. The birds are going to eat whatever mosquitoes are there. And it's not long standing water either. So you don't get a chance for mosquitoes laying eggs that.

Speaker 9

Yeah, I'm generally familiar with how they work and kind of what they look like. And then is a, Chris may have asked this already when I walked back in, there'll be a maintenance agreement that's made with MSD?

Speaker 13

Yes, we've already provided a signed notarized maintenance agreement to MSD. We've already paid the recording fee. So MSD should be in the process of recording that with St. Louis County while, you know, and I should get notice of that when they notify me of plan approval.

Speaker 9

And they come out, was it once a year and check it or is it less often than that?

Speaker 13

Actually, they don't, but there's reporting

Speaker 9

that. The owner has to report on it, correct?

Speaker 13

Yeah, that's how it's been. I think MSD is changing the rules on that for residential projects.

Speaker 9

Okay.

Speaker 13

But there's still a maintenance. You're probably outside. There's an operation and maintenance manual that I had to write. as part of the whole MSD approval. It's mostly boilerplate, but it instructs the homeowner, the occupant resident, how to maintain this, what they need to do on what kind of schedule.

Speaker 9

Okay, okay. And you said you explored the rest of the site and you, given the first floor size, which is large, you didn't have a different place you could put it?

Speaker 13

There really is not an alternative location. And this location also allows that large street tree in the front left corner to remain because the main excavation is outside that structural root zone.

Speaker 9

Okay, okay. That's probably all my comments. Thanks. All right. Susan.

Speaker 10

Yeah, I think it's, I hope we get more and more accustomed to seeing the retention basins versus engineering pop-up solutions and all that for the water. Also with the native plantings and the canopy you're doing, uh, that will help with the water flow as well, much less, much more so than patios and, um, just all the turf. So, um, I'm excited to see what that would look like. The pictures are always nice. Um, the only other, um, comment I have and I think this is helped somewhat by the canopy and the native plantings but right as soon as you finish here tonight we're being asked to adopt some new standards and one of those standards is recognizing the preference to avoiding the dark roofs and things like that because of the heat that it generates into the house or retains as well as the urban heat island effect that it has in the neighborhood and this is very very dark so I again that comes after you on the agenda um but uh if you could consider that uh going a little lighter color i think would be something that would benefit the neighborhood and the comfort inside the home itself yeah

Speaker 13

that'll be that'll be for the architect and the melman brothers right

Speaker 10

okay and i'm happy you're preserving that old older tree the tornado left for us and uh yeah yeah it looks good thanks

Speaker 1

any uh comments from the audience No? Okay. I'm sorry?

Speaker 3

I had one thing.

Speaker 1

Oh, sure.

Speaker 3

I just wanted to tell you guys, there is MSD actually added a rain garden to one of our neighbor's houses at the corner of Brighton Way and Forsyth. So for anybody, and they did the whole thing. And it's in the front of the house, and it looks really nice. Nice to see your guys' new build. It's the silversmiths. Anyways, just FYI.

Speaker 13

If you want to do field trips, there's plenty of rain gardens. Yeah, it looks nice.

Speaker 1

Well, they have bigger lots also. Yes,

Speaker 13

yes.

Speaker 1

Any further comments? I think, Eric, you've gone over the following condition in the staff report about the MSD plan approval. So that'll be in it. If there are no other comments.

Speaker 10

Can I add one thing? Yes. the homeowner decided to go with a little lighter color can the motion be such to allow that change in the darkness of the roof or not how would you

Speaker 1

i think we put that in the architectural

Speaker 10

oh that's true you're right you're right sorry

Speaker 13

what made me responsible for a roof

Speaker 1

if there are no uh further comments do we have a motion

Speaker 4

Yes, I move to approve as submitted with the staff condition regarding the bioretention area.

Speaker 1

Second. All in favor? Aye. Okay. Thank you, Eric. We'll move on to 73 Arundel, the architectural review. And again, we will start with the staff report. Obie?

Speaker 11

The existing house at 73 Rundle is a two-story, primarily red brick building with stone accents. Although the current proposal departs from the style of that, it largely retains the colors and materials with a similar color palette. Black architectural shingles are proposed for the main roof, with black metal for the overhang covering the front entry. The architectural review guidelines require that at least 75% of every facade has a primary material, brick or stone masonry. The proposal meets this guideline with the front facade nearly 96% masonry, the left elevation 98%, the right elevation just over 98%, and the rear elevation just over 80%. Fiber, cement, stucco panels making up the rest. The proposed garage does not meet these material guidelines with the rear alley-facing facade 59% brick, then the two sides just over 22%, and then the house-facing facade 19%. The applicant is requesting a modification of the material requirements for the garage, referencing the proposed landscape and privacy fence screening, as well as the presence of other non-masonry garages elsewhere on the block. Given these examples, staffer of the opinion that the proposed facade composition would not have a substantial visual impact. The new house would be two stories and 27 feet, seven inches tall from the average main grid to the average roof slope. The roof line largely matches the property to the west slightly higher than the property of the east. Stafford, the opinion that the perceived height will not be out of place from the street or sidewalk. The proposed layout is somewhat different in that the second floor will be roughly one-third as large as the first floor, with two bedrooms on each level, with the primary bedroom on the first floor. Since the new house is significantly longer than the current house, the view from the alley into the two neighbors would be primarily that of the roof. So staff for the opinion that the dormers are some different technique to break up the roof monotony should be added or the slope change to reduce the height to mitigate this feature on the one story portion. The materials, The current project scope largely matches the architectural review guidelines. The areas where it departs from those are largely out of public view, and because of that, staff are of the opinion that with slight modifications, the proposal is compatible with the site and the surrounding area. Staff recommend approval with the following condition, that the one-story portion of the house be revised to provide greater visual interest than the current roof design.

Speaker 14

Thank you. Lauren? Good evening. My name is Lauren Strutman, and I'll start by covering the materials for the new house. Okay. And we've got mixed red brick, natural Indiana limestone on the windows in the front of the house. On the rear of the house and on the garage, we're proposing a James Hardy stucco board with James Hardy trim. We think that's more interesting and more in keeping with the neighborhood than horizontal lap type siding features on the garage and the back of the house. And our roof is a black architectural single roof. This house was specifically designed for our clients with two main level bedrooms and two bedrooms upstairs so that's really the reason why we don't have as big an upstairs is a downstairs it's actually not a very big House. Between the main level in the upper level it's just 3148 square feet, which is honestly. quite a bit smaller than the usual homes we present here in Clayton, which tend to be in the 4,000 or a little over 4,000 square feet. I do want to mention we have written approval from the Hillcrest trustees, and we have gotten some neighbors' approval. No neighbors have objected to the house. And I would like to at this time address the two comments that staff made had um we actually think it's a nice idea to lower the roof in the back a little bit and if ryan were to scroll down on our uh drawings here i put a couple of drawings on the keep going oh yeah it's on the file from eric beat buyer um normally we use the same roof pitches on the front of the house than on the back of the house. But because the back of the House is larger, what we're suggesting is to change the roof pitch going side to side on the back of a house to be a 612 instead of an 812. And it does really lower the mass of that roof. You can see it there on the screen in comparison. I know your staff suggestion was either to lower the roof or add dormers in our clients don't really want to put fake dormers on the roof. What we've just done is, is lowered it to lower the scale. And, uh, the pitch facing the North to the rear is still an eight 12, but the main pitch of the main body of the roof, uh, going from side to side has been reduced to six 12. And I think that's a proven you'll like, um, So you can see there on the back of the house, the house is all brick, except for we do have the stucco board with trim on that upper second floor area that's facing the backyard. And we matched that look on the detached garage. And actually I spent some time, if you were to scroll down to the next couple of slides or scroll up, It should be on that same flash drive. Yeah, there's a picture of the garage, but if you go to the flash drive that Eric Biedmeier brought in with his material, I took pictures of a lot of the garages There we go. It's interesting, I took pictures of 11 garages and there's only one that's kind of a nice looking cedar shingle siding. But the other 10 that I took pictures of are all have the same brick corners, the same thing as what we're doing here on 73 or Wendell. It was surprising to me. And in some cases, the brick corners are painted the same color as the horizontal lap siding, like on that gray garage. So it's not as obvious that it's a brick corner. But there's basically siding and brick corners on 10 garages right in the area. And these examples are 10 pictures of that and one picture of the one with the. cedar shingle siding. So that's why we went with that look and a lot of these garages with the brick corners have vinyl siding in between or horizontal lap and we've gone with the James Hardy stucco board with the trim to give it a little different flair more in keeping with the house. So that's we're proposing a garage like this as well as our client is a very avid gardener and they see the The siding areas as a garage is more of a backdrop for some beautiful landscaping rather than everything being the dark red brick on the garage. And if you were looking at the garage from the alley, you pretty much see all brick and then there'll be a fence, a privacy fence. And the areas that have the siding are basically in their garden that is shown by Baxter Gardens. you can look at every single one of those has brick corners it's kind of surprising how prevalent that is even the one like the white one um it's all one color so it's not so easy to see but so i'm here to answer any questions you all have about the project

Speaker 1

Okay. Thank you, Lauren. I have a couple things. I'm glad you lowered that rear roof. I think it'll look much better from the neighbor's point of view, especially. And I think Susan's comments about lightening it up could be uh very beneficial i know i replaced my roof after the tornado and we went with a lighter roof and we had a much lower air conditioning bill even though we had a lot of heat this summer so the suggestion um the uh i like the james hardy trim, a stucco board. But I was wondering, as you heard what we were talking about in the previous application, if the lower portion could also be brick because the house itself doesn't have any James Hardy coming down to the ground. And I think it... If we had the brick coming down the corners and going along underneath the window, I think it could be even closer in relation to the house. It's a suggestion also. Okay. And then I think my third one was when we look at the contextual drawing on A7. I like how the house is sitting there, and I'm glad that you're not going to change the slope of the front roof because with the height of the house, anything lower, the roof will tend to disappear. Right. So that was fine. But I was wondering about the necessity of the windows in the basement. And the house number 71, the house to the right, seems to be much more grounded to the ground. And the first floor of the new house will be much higher than that one. Yet when I look at the house at 75, it is higher also. So I was wondering if the house could be brought down a little.

Speaker 14

Actually, we looked pretty carefully at the height of the house and worked with Eric Vietmeyer on it. And looking at that contextual elevation, there's a good six feet of difference in the street from left to right in terms of how much it does drop. And we do have, if you look at 75, which is the house on the left, that house is one foot higher. And then if you look at the house over on the right, it's about two and a half feet lower, but it's pretty much following the street. And our clients do have plans to finish this lower level in the future. because they don't have a very big house, they planned to expand kind of a recreation room down there and very much wanted the daylight without window wells. And we did work out the height of this house very carefully with Eric, so we were draining the yard properly. And they would rather have some daylight on the first floor. They also like a little bit the privacy of a house not being right down at at street level, and it's also, to me, very compatible with the slope on the street and with the neighbors on the left and the right. We were very careful about that height. What

Speaker 1

are the floor-to-floor heights? First floor?

Speaker 14

Ten foot and nine foot. Pretty normal floor heights for new homes, yeah.

Speaker 1

Well, those are normal, but I think they're higher than either of the houses on

Speaker 14

either side. But they are. We also have a lot of new energy codes in Clayton that are very much enforced where the roof trusses tend to have a heel or a leg on them to get a very high R value in the attic. And those are all parts of complying with our Clayton energy codes. Okay.

Speaker 1

We'll go around. Helen?

Speaker 4

I like the lower level being shown. I like the windows. I like how you've kept them in keeping with the windows on the first floor and second. I think seeing the lower level windows treated as you have is very reminiscent of the older homes where you see that they haven't brought the concrete foundation up and then you try to obscure that lower level um generally planted so that nobody sees it. But here, I think I like it. I disagree with Steve. The one thing that bothers me when I look at the front elevation is that you have two brick columns, their piers coming down. And then right under that visually, you have a wood column. I know it's a different plane. Is there sufficient distance between the two that when you see them in reality, it won't look like brick columns sitting on wood?

Speaker 14

If you look at the side elevation, the brick columns continue down the front of the house. You can see that line there, that's the brick columns. Right there. That's the brick. And then the wood column is substantially in front of there. There's a gap. And you can see that on the side elevation.

Speaker 4

Okay. How much of a gap is there? There were no dimensions for that.

Speaker 14

The overall porch is five feet out. Okay. Because that's the code on how much a porch can project. And the brick columns are just very shallow pilasters against the house. You can see on that side elevation, they're only about 12 inches out.

Speaker 4

Okay. Yeah. The five feet will be better. There's

Speaker 14

a good distance here.

Speaker 4

Yeah.

Speaker 14

Enough room for a railing in between.

Speaker 4

Yeah, it's probably more a factor of the rendering on a seven and then the color rendering cover sheet. Now, I think it looks good. You know, when will it be finished?

Speaker 7

Yeah. Yeah, continuing on with Steve and Helen's comments. I think I would probably be a little more in the Steve camp in the sense that I don't like those windows there as much, but I understand them because looking at the context and yes, just like you said, this isn't a very big house. So I feel like if you did take that down, you really reduce the opportunities for light to get in that lower level and makes it less usable. On top of that, too, I think a lot of times where you see multiple steps like this, a house is hanging way above. But if you look at the gutter line compared to 75, it's pretty equal. And with the slope, I don't think there's any reason why you would necessarily have to match the lower gutter line as opposed to the higher gutter line. And like you said, I don't My only concern with all this is it's more just a thought. I wanted your thoughts on this, that a lot of the reason for this plan of being more space on the bottom as opposed to the top was aging in place. And yet there's four steps in the front and there's four steps back. And I didn't know if there was any thought given to ways to treat either one of those entrances to make it more aging in place friendly to getting in the house. I know once you're in the house, circulation would be easier, but with four steps in the front and the back, I didn't know if there was any way, if that had been given any thought.

Speaker 14

Actually, we had quite a few discussions with the clients about the steps and the number of steps and their current living situation has even more. And the thought was that in the back, a ramp could always be done on the steps in the rear if, if it came to that. And, uh, we've been very much involved in discussing the number of steps and I appreciate the suggestion, but this is where they want it to be in terms of height. Understood.

Speaker 7

Um, and I, I agree that I think the six 12 pitch on the sides, uh, really visually reduces that. So I, uh, I was thinking along the line with the dormer's suggestion, but once I saw the renderings there, I think that's a completely workable solution. Thank you. Chris?

Speaker 8

I agree with the reduction in the roof. I think it makes a big difference. I was in the camp of doing dormers until you suggested that, and I don't find the lowered roof objectionable. I think the house is beautiful and a very nice job. I like the brick accents on the side. You've done a nice job of preserving some of the features of the original house but modernizing it. The windows on the first floor here, are those French windows? Are those fixed-in-place windows? How will that?

Speaker 14

They're casement windows.

Speaker 8

They're casement Windows here. Okay. I don't have any concerns with them. I think it looks nice. Thank you.

Speaker 3

Hi. I loved the front elevation. I like the front and the back elevation, actually. I like the relationship that this hits 275. So I think that that, to me, really leveled out. I do like the addition of the windows in the basement. I think that that's really advantageous for future use. I am uh struggling with the garage elevations and seeing the relationship of those to the home so similar to what steve was saying um i do think that it's important to add brick and have a better relationship between the back elevation and the garage

Speaker 9

jeff all right thanks um Help me a little bit with the size of the first floor. Where does the back facade of the first floor of the house sit in relationship to the neighbors on either side? I don't think it really shows on the site plan unless I'm missing it. Because while he's doing that, I'm getting older myself. I fully understand the idea of as much of a first floor as possible that's accessible to age in place. It's just the size of the first floor compared to the size of a very small second floor is interesting massing.

Speaker 3

Did the existing house, was that in relationship to the adjacent houses back? No. I'm

Speaker 9

talking about the

Speaker 15

neighbors. Yeah,

Speaker 3

yeah. This one, how it related to the existing ones.

Speaker 15

Yeah, so on the screen Ryan has it, you can see the ends were added of the houses on either side and right under, basically in between those is where the existing house ends and the new house goes all the way back to where you can see it says screened porch. the new house goes back to that

Speaker 9

so it's a substantially larger first floor foot than the neighbors right um which we run into a lot with new construction these days um and they're um yeah i just think that's unfortunate but like i said i understand the the need for as much first floor space as possible if you're trying to age in place in the house um I don't have a problem with the front design. I wish it was a little more interesting. I'm actually kind of lamenting the loss of the existing building, the existing house on that site, because while it's very different, it's kind of a funky little house. And this is more of a stayed sort of a classical approach, which is less interesting to me architecturally, just honestly. But I see what you're trying to do. I don't have a problem with showing a little of the first floor and down, so I like when entrances are raised up a little bit from grade. So... It's really my biggest struggle here is just with the overall massing of the house, how much first floor there is and how little second floor there is. To begin with, the garage bothered me a bit, but with the way you've described it and the way you've detailed it, it doesn't bother me that much in terms of... And I see it's interesting, the brick corners on the neighboring garages, which is kind of strange. It makes me wonder if they were... Some of them are carpets or something to start with and they added siding later. But I think it, I don't mind that entirely. So mostly just I wish the massing was a little different, but I see why you're doing what you're doing. Thanks. Susan.

Speaker 10

Yeah, the corners on the garages that were brick that I was surprised by that too. I hadn't really noticed that before. I think it's beautiful. I love the recreational options for the basement with the windows coming in, with the light coming in. I think that's well in the neighborhood. You heard my comments about the roof color. I hope that that might be something you'd consider lightening up a little bit or just the black all over. So aside from that, I look forward to seeing it as part of the neighborhood.

Speaker 1

Any comments from the audience? Any further comments? Barn, you have any further?

Speaker 14

I mean, we would prefer to leave the garage as it is, but that's up to the board.

Speaker 1

Well, what I said before, I think it looks good. I just felt it would relate to the house if it were grounded with brick as the house is. But I'm okay. Any other comments? Well, we do have a staff recommendation. I think it's taken care of. And we also have a recommendation about the shingle color. Was there anything else?

Speaker 14

Yeah, I think clients would like to keep the darker shingle. It will be a well-ventilated roof. I know that's their first choice. It's really called like a charcoal blend or it's not pitch black roof, but I think this is a good representation of the roof that will be on the house.

Speaker 1

Well, let's do a motion and see where it goes.

Speaker 4

Okay. I move to approve as submitted with the lower slope for the first floor roof as described.

Speaker 1

Second. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Thank you very much. You're on the way. When is demolition to start? Okay. Well, good luck with it. It'll be a beautiful addition to the neighborhood and it's nice that the clients are relocating.

Speaker 12

Thank you.

Speaker 1

Okay, we've come to item four on our agenda, and that's the Neighborhood Design Guidelines Review. And let's see, Ana, I think you're going to start.

Speaker 15

Yes, so I don't really need to go through the document again. We made some minor changes based on feedback from when the Architecture Review Board looked at it previously as well as after. uh discussion session with the city council so updated some of the images added some additional notes that clarify the alignment requirements and goals and some additional wording updates

Speaker 1

Well, having read through it again and then comparing it to what we looked at on October 19th, I see there are minor clarifications throughout it. But I did have a couple questions, and I think we mentioned it on the October review. When we say PVC material and it shows up on page four, Does that include Trex or similar type materials?

Speaker 15

There's plastic within some of the composites, but what we've been doing recently is approving the ones that are not just purely plastic mixes. So Trex does have other elements, but if there's If there are some other specific materials that we would want to go through, I think we can do that as a separate point to go through different brands. I don't know in this document here is not where I would recommend us starting to list what brands of different products we're going to allow or not allow.

Speaker 1

Well, as long as we're open to some composite materials in the future,

Speaker 15

We do allow composites. We just don't allow pure plastic, so you can't come in and get a vinyl. But we do see a lot of Trex and other ones. And when we see new brands, we'll request the documents about that brand that tell us what the mix of materials are that are going into that composite. So typically, we lean towards a wood composite. So there's still some natural material within the mix.

Speaker 1

Thank you. And then I'm still a little confused. I think on pages 10 and 14, I can't quite figure out the difference between Beamiston, North Beamiston, and Beamiston East Side. To me, they all look alike. I went over to walk around that area.

Speaker 15

You mean why they're in different typologies? Yeah, they're in different topologies because it goes back to the base zoning districts and the lot size characteristics. So here with type B, the east portion of Bemiston that's highlighted to be included in type B has wider lots on average and is all zoned R2. Then when you get into the other portions of Bemiston, that includes neighborhoods that are zoned with our one and two family district, R3. And they have narrower lots as well as some of the neighborhoods that are actually under a PUD because they were constructed through a planned residential district prior to our current PUD regulations. So that zoning district no longer exists. So they were rezoned into the PUD. So that's kind of how we differentiated between the typologies.

Speaker 1

Okay, I think that's clear to me now. Okay. I have to go back and walk it again. Sure.

Speaker 4

Yeah, I did go through it again. And I think it's excellent. I mean, yeah, anything can be tweaked and you can go on forever doing that. But I think you've gotten it. And the Bemisden area and then Wydown Forest, there are a couple of areas where they've kind of grown and now we're trying to understand them and fill in further. So I think you've done a great job. couldn't find anything wrong so thank you

Speaker 7

yeah i think a lot of the changes we had mentioned were minor to start with and i see a lot of them coming up just even how pictures are labeled and everything like that um yeah i like the fact too that this is you know here we do have a new codified zoning in clayton in a lot of these spaces But this is a little more flexible as guidelines. And I think it's so much stronger of a baseline than where we're starting from now as just giving people a good idea of where to start. And I think also with this not being codified, it allows us a little more flexibility to kind of adapt with the times. If we start seeing swings in any direction that need to be mentioned, it's something that's maybe not as onerous of a process than redoing zoning. So maybe we can push off the next zoning change that much further by a process like this. But I'm interested to hear the comments that come up, but I think you guys did a great job. Chris.

Speaker 8

I agree. Great job on it. Really, really nice. The only thing I would ask is that, um, since I imagine that most of the time someone will be viewing this online, um, that the pictures and I'm looking for example, on page eight, that those pictures maybe be just when you click on them, that they go to a full screen sort of image. Um, because the architectural details on there, they're just hard to see unless you know specifically what you're looking for just because the size of the photos. So I, that's the only suggestion I would have it. Um, But I found it really easy to go through. I love how the illustrations and diagrams kind of really complement the pictures that you've got both of those. So I think it's an excellent job. Thank you.

Speaker 3

i would second everybody else i think uh i think the yes and no is a lot clearer now um so great job on you know i guess listening and revising and looks really good so um nothing further for me

Speaker 9

beth yeah thanks again for all the work um the only question i've got And I don't know, maybe we've run into this already before my time. The type D neighborhoods, I would imagine where we or some future board are going to be dealing with potential two-story incursions into this neighborhood, either building on top of an existing one-story or taking a one-story down and building a two-story house. And it references that a little bit here, but... not as strong as I'd maybe like to. I don't know what the guidelines should be there. I don't if that's allowed, I don't know if we imagine this neighborhood would change over the years and this type of low-slung home be gone at some point, or if we want to keep this neighborhood as a single story, more 50s modern. et cetera, sort of a neighborhood. So that's the one thing in here that's... And maybe this board doesn't need that analysis. Maybe we do it on a case-by-case basis, but I think it would be good for somebody looking at the neighborhood attempting to build something different, which I think is probably going to happen if it hasn't already. How should they approach it? um that's my only that's a

Speaker 15

good point this that neighborhood is actually currently covered by an urban design district so part of the residential phase two projects that um ryan and hobie are working on is evaluating those overlay urban design districts so that that is probably going to be part of a conversation that you'll be having with you i don't whichever one of them leads that discussion at that point um to go into a little bit more detail I mean, it's a

Speaker 9

personal bias. I love mid-century modern houses. I don't know if these all qualifies that, but they could, or even new houses like that could. And it just becomes a different sort of a neighborhood in Clayton that has a different sort of interest to it as opposed to the stock build two-story, fill up as much of the site as you can approach that a lot of developers are taking these days. So that was my only thought. Thanks. Yeah,

Speaker 10

that's a really interesting point. The only other thing I have to add is more thanks. It looks really good. Thank you.

Speaker 1

Well, from what Jeff was talking about, the Clayshire area, which is type D, I believe we do have a two-story house in there.

Speaker 15

Yes, there are a couple. Two of them are – I included pictures of a couple of them. So there's a handful of multi-story, but really I think maybe four or five

Speaker 9

total. Were they recently built? I just don't know.

Speaker 15

Yes, there is. There are a few that are a little bit older and there's also a multifamily that's mixed into the neighborhood that actually is, I think, two and a half stories, if I recall. But there are three two story homes that have been built within the last 10 years. I believe 10 to 15 years in the neighborhood. And two of the three are shown because they include significant step downs. So that under that urban design district, that the infill strategies that they used were the increased side yard setback on one side and a step down on the other.

Speaker 10

These were teardowns, not...

Speaker 15

That's correct. These

Speaker 9

two that are pictured. Right, like the lower left picture in the alternate massing. Yeah, yeah. Because this is, I mean, this is a lot of, there's a lot of neighborhoods around the country that are struggling with exactly this. I've seen it in Los Angeles. I've seen that in Texas. I've seen in all kinds of places. And it's kind of what's the long-term view of the city as to what the neighborhood should become? If that's the question. I don't know the answer, but... Thanks.

Speaker 3

I have something else to add. Not in regards to that, but that's a really valid conversation. I am missing in here and maybe this is just the wrong document because I know that we went through this previously. The discussion about second story garage slash accessory structures. So is that intentionally not in here?

Speaker 15

Right. So we actually codified those regulations with the recent overhaul of the residential zoning. So that's where we now have the restrictions for the reduced sider setback for an accessory structure. We also introduced the restrictions on the size of dormers and the size of a half story as it relates to the floor below it. So those are all in our actual zoning ordinance.

Speaker 13

Yep.

Speaker 1

I believe we have a comment from the audience.

Speaker 16

Hello, my name is Kathleen Gund. I live at 329 North Bemiston and I have a request and then also a comment. So I've spoken and written about the, it is a recent and it is a trendy use of gas lamps on a lot of the new high-end residential developments around Clayton, particularly north of the downtown area. They release carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide and methane into the air. They are wasteful regarding energy use. And they are on, most of them are on 24-7, 365 days a year, not just during the time when it is dark. So I have been unsuccessful in getting the city to prohibit their installation going forward. But I have gotten a bit of traction in having some of you question their continued use. So if we were to go to page four of this document under the lighting section, there's a very weirdly... This is a great document, but it was kind of like weirdly written that alternative fuel power sources for gas lanterns should be considered to reduce the environmental impacts while still providing the stylistic element of the traditional fixtures. Very confusing because a gas lantern... is a lantern that uses gas. So I don't know why we're talking about alternative fuel power sources. So I'm not really sure what the statement means, but it's right underneath sustainability and they're not sustainable. And I think that we should replace that with a statement that reads something like, while not strictly prohibited, the use of gas lanterns for exterior lighting is discouraged due to sustainability concerns. So I'm hoping you'll make the change to that document and Uh, that's my request. Um, the comment I have, um, relates to, um, I'm just speaking of the sea areas, which I live, um, north of here in old town and, um, in the material section, I know this is kind of like nitty gritty or whatever, but, um, and Helen, you can support me on this. I've lived up there for 34 years. All the homes up there used to be, um, sided, not all, but most of them used to be sided and then they were replaced by brick. And I think there's a bias towards brick among this group and just around Clayton, but the original structures that still exist are really nice. And I'd hate to, if someone were to tear them down and replace them, like it would be nice to have more siding up there. And there's even a picture on, if you would go to the, where it has like a, the C section and there's like what to do and what not to do. So one more. Oh, it's the blue house. Right, right. The next one, garages and accessories. Okay. So see the house that's like the second from the left that's like blue? That's siding. That's a new house. That's infill. It's beautiful. And so I just wanted to kind of tout for my neighborhood that the next time someone comes to you and has like an idea that they want siding on their house, like... the neighbors are thumbs up on that. I know there's a bias towards brick, but I know the person who's doing the new house at Kingsbury and central kind of had to argue a little bit like I want siding. I want siding, I don't want brick. And I think some people weren't really happy with that, but as the neighbors who are there, we like it, or at least I do. That's it. Thank you very much.

Speaker 9

Can I comment on that, Steve? I very much agree with the comment about, especially what I'd consider traditional old town houses north of Forsyth that were sited, that were shaked, that were beautiful. And I think it's some of the- Yeah, but a combination. I mean, it's... Yeah, I think it's unfortunate the way that neighborhood has transitioned to kind of boring brick.

Speaker 16

Well, no, a lot of the brick is nice, but it's just the overabundance of it gets... It's much heavier.

Speaker 3

Right.

Speaker 16

And I just wanted to kind of remind people that the work that was done by assessing all the neighborhoods was, like, amazing, but... I've been there for 34 years and you miss what used to be there. And a lot of what used to be, there was like falling down sided houses, which needed to be replaced. But, um, for that specific neighborhood, um, the houses that still exist, like the beeline house, um, it's right there. It's siding.

Speaker 3

Oh,

Speaker 16

well, anyways, we just still call it the line house. So it's, it's cited. So thank you.

Speaker 10

That required loosening up something. Some of the language of this recommendation is

Speaker 16

guidelines.

Speaker 15

It doesn't require any changes because we talk about how you should look at the context of your neighborhood, but we can always add a specific call out if you want to that says that that neighborhood, because we have call-outs throughout sometimes that identify how a specific neighborhood within a typology may differ from the other neighborhoods of that same typology in one element or another. So under materials, we could add a call-out to the historic nature of siting use in that area and cover it.

Speaker 1

Would you want it to be limited to siting? Or, well, I guess stone would also be masonry.

Speaker 15

Well, I don't know if there was the same historic pattern of all stone houses or not. So if you want to call that out, we can.

Speaker 1

No, I'm just wondering if calling it out with a specific, no, I think calling it out to relate to the historical nature might be the best way. Not with a particular material.

Speaker 3

I would agree with that, too. I think that similar to how, you know, people are coming in here now and saying, you know, we want 25 percent brick or whatever it is, you know, sort of disputing their case. I think similar situation. So I would also stay away from specific material calling out. But the historic nature, I think, is nice.

Speaker 15

Yep. As long as we continue to have the institutional knowledge of that nature, because I don't think citing dominates it anymore based on the study. So yeah, we would have to have that knowledge that it used to and that we want to bring it back is the only piece specifically with citing because for so many years, our guidelines have essentially dissuaded everybody from using citing moving forward. And this is the result is now we no longer have that pattern of citing. So yeah, If they're right now, the way that these guidelines are written, just as we saw tonight, it encourages people to make their case and identify it so we can leave it that way. Or if you specifically with this instance of siting in this neighborhood want to promote that as a design choice that we want people to consider, then I would recommend adding that specific reference.

Speaker 16

Can I just say one more thing? That's not my request when I came up here. I just said if you would consider thinking about that, I really think that you need to change the thing about the lighting.

Speaker 10

And I would support that. This actually came before the Sustainability Committee when we had a lot of other things going on and the methane gas leaking. It's an ornamental fixture. They don't serve any purpose anymore, but it's become very common in some of the new construction to have the gas lights without a lot of benefits and there are alternatives. So The more we can discourage it, I would support doing that.

Speaker 3

I second that.

Speaker 8

Yeah, I think it's a good recommendation. The language that you used for it I think was great, that it's not a strong – it's not a ban. And I have gas lanterns in our house. We turned them off a couple of months ago, and then we turned them back on for Halloween. And then – We haven't turned them back off again, but I'm going to go home tonight and turn them back off. So it's one of those things. But I do like the language. I think that's not objectionable. And if someone wants to stick their heels in and say, I really want to have gas lanterns, then it does open up this kind of these conversations. Yeah.

Speaker 4

On the siding side. I would leave that out and, as Steve mentioned, refer to the historical nature and then let the applicant plead their case because I think with siding, and I suspect the reason people were steered away from it, is that the vinyl siding does not look like wood. And even referencing historical, you can look through catalogs online any place and see that, you know, they will say this is a historical sighting. Well, it's vinyl. And the maintenance is horrendous, you know, a hail storm and how many dings qualify, you know, convince someone to replace it. And then can you get the color? I think if we do it and this, the guidelines already allow us to make exceptions to, you know, look at something that's different so the one on the corner of central and kingsbury that's siding but we saw that the siding that's being used the corners the mitered corners and things we could verify that because we had a manufacturer's name if we allow you know or encourage siding we're going to be fighting vinyl and every other PVC that will not look good down the line. So as a resident of old town for 40, 50 years, I would not put it in.

Speaker 7

Yeah. I think to piggyback on that a little bit, um, I agree with your thinking because I think my memory of the house on Central was the siding was approved rather easily because of the justification that they did give. I would worry that if we pushed people towards siding, we would get a kind of siding or we would get a sided house that we weren't necessarily as happy with probably. than if someone came to it naturally. And I think the people who would come to it naturally would come probably in a bit more of a historical sense on that. With the gas lanterns, as far as in this guideline book, I don't know if this is the document to make a strong change. And I think if we're going to go in a direction where we're discussing either banning gas lanterns or strongly not recommending them, I think that should be something that's more codified versus this. So I think we should go about it in a different way and have that built into the zoning or built into something that's not suggested guidelines.

Speaker 3

To that point then, I think that the note that actually says gas lanterns should just be just that part taken off then. I hear what you're saying.

Speaker 10

So to allow or not to allow or not mention? What do you say? I

Speaker 3

mean, I agree in that we should not put a ban on them, but we should highly recommend them not being used. But Kathleen pointed to a specific page

Speaker 1

I

Speaker 3

think that where it says lighting and says the alternative fuel, then maybe we just take that out altogether on this document versus actually putting in under lighting using gas lanterns as an alternative fuel.

Speaker 7

Well, the ironic thing is I think it's probably in there for this specific situation.

Speaker 15

Yeah, the reason that wording was there is because we've heard people, they associate a certain aesthetic when you say gas lantern. And so the idea being that instead of gas, you get the aesthetic of a gas lantern, but you're using an alternative source.

Speaker 16

That doesn't come through, in my opinion, with what's up there. Yeah. So I don't know if you want to say like, we love flickering, you know, I just, I just think that I've been in front of this board many, many times. Well, not many, that's an exaggeration that I do not understand why, like, I don't think we should like make people take them out of their houses, but like, It's literally like air pollution for no reason, because people like them. They're not historical. Most of the homes here were built between 1910 and 1920 when all residential lighting was moved to electric. There were gas lights that were basic, like exterior lights that were basically phased out in the 1950s and 1960s. And there are still some that exist. But like, historically, they're not like a part of Clayton, like they're on primarily high end new residences. It's like a trend. And I think we should, like, I think if people were actually told, you know, this is like worsening air pollution, they'd be like, oh, I just, I put them on my house because I thought it was pretty. So I think that we need to say, while not strictly prohibited, the use of gas lanterns for exterior lighting is discouraged due to sustainability concerns. It's guidance. We're giving people guidance.

Speaker 10

I'm going to push back a little bit because I think that this language does capture, you can still have your flickering lights. but you don't have to use a gas light. I understand what you're saying, but this is kind of...

Speaker 7

I personally, at least from, and maybe Blair can speak to this too. Like as a designer, I take that language of a lot of these gas lantern manufacturers basically make an electrified version of the exact same lamp. And that's how I read this document as someone who would be designing a home. So while the effect might not come through necessarily, like that's how I interpret it at least.

Speaker 16

Okay. If it's not gas, it's not a gas lantern. It's an electric lantern that looks like gas. But

Speaker 10

it is by the aesthetic they're going for. People may be using it loosely.

Speaker 8

Does this set of quotes help? Like gas-style lanterns? Or something in quotes? I'm wondering if there's some way... Because I think that you're focused on the fact that it's not a Aesthetic. Yeah, the aesthetic of that. So maybe clarifying something that it's guest lantern style. I still like the language that you used better.

Speaker 16

Thank you. I worked

Speaker 3

hard on it. I think this statement while reading it, it is exactly what I think should happen. And I am not my writing skills are Well, very poor. So I can't rewrite this, but I lean towards something in that nature or just rewriting this statement.

Speaker 15

I mean, I think... the purpose here was the aesthetics. I can rework the wording to make that more clear, but if there's a separate request under sustainability to have anything else related to gas lanterns, then we can add that. But I can change this wording slightly to make it more clear that this was, we understand there's a desire, gas lanterns is being used in the term of aesthetics and we would prefer if you want that look to not have it be served by gas

Speaker 3

thank you that's exactly what i'm looking

Speaker 15

for so i'll i'll make sure that that wording gets a little bit clearer and we can provide it to you and that's the nice part about this document being adopted by the architecture v board is that i can provide you in the next for the next meeting how that language has been updated i'm

Speaker 10

even saying discouraged due to the environmental impact great

Speaker 1

any other comments Kathleen, nothing else? Well, are we to approve it tonight or wait for the revision?

Speaker 15

So you can approve just like anything else. You could do a motion to approve with the condition that the language for gas lanterns is updated per this discussion, and we will do that. And then we'll make sure at the next meeting that you are made aware of the language change that we've made, and we can always edit it further if need be.

Speaker 1

Thank you. We'll do that.

Speaker 4

Okay, I move to approve the neighborhood design guidelines as submitted with the rewriting of this section on gas lanterns to be updated per tonight's discussion.

Speaker 1

Second. All in favor? Aye. Moved. Good discussion. So thank you, everybody. So, Jeff, any further comments? Nope, nothing. Thanks. Blair?

Speaker 3

Not for me, thank you.

Speaker 1

Chris?

Speaker 8

Happy Thanksgiving early, you all.

Speaker 7

Tim? Thank you guys for spending my birthday with me.

Speaker 1

Ellen?

Speaker 10

Happy Thanksgiving.

Speaker 1

Susan?

Speaker 10

Thank you for sharing a birthday with my son.

Speaker 1

Brian? Nothing further. You've been quiet tonight. Yeah, place change. Obie?

Speaker 11

Nothing for me.

Speaker 1

Anna?

Speaker 15

I just want to say thank you to Kevin. I believe this is the last Plain Commission meeting with you. been great thank you for your assistance and your guidance over many many years and many many difficult topics for the plan commission in the city of playton to navigate so thank you for all of your your time and efforts and and you will be missed very

Speaker 1

kind

Speaker 15

thank you

Speaker 10

pleasure to know you and to have worked with you so thank you

Speaker 1

i i would agree with those comments and uh hopefully you'll come back and visit I'll keep it on my calendar, indeed. Good. Thank you. Okay. Well, okay, everyone. We will see you in three weeks, is

Speaker 7

it?

Speaker 1

December 14th, yeah. Oh, yeah, Mom. Okay. Enjoy your turkey, and we'll see you on the 14th. We're adjourned.