Document

transcript · Board meeting video

November 10, 2026 — Meeting Transcript

Meeting video
Chapters
Full transcript

Speaker labels are inferred from the recording; proper names are corrected against the public record. How this works ↗

Speaker 1

Good evening. We're here for our 630 discussion session. It's Tuesday, November 10th. And Ryan Helle in our planning department is going to update us on tree and landscape regulations.

Good evening. We're here for our 630 discussion session. It's Tuesday, November 10th. And Ryan Helley in our planning department is going to update us on tree and landscape regulations.

Speaker 2

All righty. I know that we want to be time sensitive here. I promise I only have like seven slides, including this one. So I'm going to try to get through this as briefly as possible. We're still trying to cover as much as we can. So as a reminder, as part of our comprehensive planning process, we're taking a look at the tree and landscape regulations to see if there's improvements that we can make in that area. So we're going to recap what our comp plan findings are. We're going to recap, what our current landscape review process is. We're going give a brief summary of the work that Brad Goss did because a lot of the work that he did has influenced the direction we're going today. If anybody was not here for Brad Goss' work, have no fear. We'll clarify who he is and what he worked on. And then I'm going to give you a brief summary of some proposed changes that we're looking at. They're pretty high level at this point. There's a couple, you know, quantifiable numbers in there, but it's mostly going to be higher level stuff and we'll be able to have some more concrete stuff here in the next couple months. So through the comprehensive planning process, some of the big takeaways in the area of landscape and tree regulations is that most of those findings landed specifically on trees. We found that the city's policies tend to be more progressive than a lot of our peer communities, so it's great to know that our tree and landscape regulations are already ahead of the curve in trying to accomplish those goals. Found that residents highly value their canopy coverage and support planting trees wherever they can. Most properties do not meet our tree planting and canopy coverage goals. Where they do meet those goals, it's kind of decentralized. There's a couple patterns out there, but generally there's not too many patterns in terms of where that tree canopy coverage can be found. Residents had a lot of concerns about construction, both during the construction process and just in general whenever folks are doing a lot of development, tearing down trees. And then during the comprehensive planning process, our consultants regularly asked the residents if they were willing to have trade-offs in favor of a stronger regulation in a certain area. Residents provided regular feedback that they thought that tree landscapes, sustainability standards, that those should just be robust from the get-go and that you should not have to have trade-off in order to have quality regulations in that area. That yielded these key results that we'll see here on the screen. So key result 3.1, prioritizing green space trees and sustainability in residential neighborhoods to retain existing character. That one's a little bit more broad, applies a variety of places, but more specifically what's kind of guided us in the direction today is 3.3, reviewing the tree and landscape regulations to further protect and enhance existing neighborhood tree canopy, especially during construction activities. So pivoting over real quick to kind of give you guys a refresher on what our landscape process currently looks like. Our landscape review regulations are going to be triggered during site plan review, special development districts and plan unit developments. So that's largely going to be your new construction, your large additions, something that's going to disturb more of the site. During that process, we're reviewing what kind of trees are getting removed, what kind of trees and plans are getting added to the site, what kind of tree protection are we going to have during construction, and then are they meeting minimums for criteria like natives and canopy coverage? And most importantly, viability for the proposal. Just because we check all of the boxes on the list does not always mean that the plans given to us are viable, so we want to make sure more than anything that what is proposed is going to last a long time. Also, I know I've been saying canopy coverage a lot. If anybody does not remember, canopy coverage is essentially how much of that tree canopy is covering a lot. It's pretty direct. The requirement for the amount of canopy coverage that you have increases as density decreases. So if you have a large single family lot, more canopy coverage, you have a really dense multifamily, really low canopy coverage requirement. Some of the challenges that we're running into during this process, number one, most importantly, is clear cutting. Typically, whenever somebody's coming in and they want to develop something new on a site, they're not always looking at retaining existing trees, and existing trees is the most important place for your canopy coverage growth. Tree and landscape regulations tend to be kind of an afterthought. The process is usually get the building, get the site features that you want, and then, oh yeah, we also have to make sure we're meeting these tree canopy goals. There's definitely impacts during construction. Some sites are better than others, but just because of the nature of construction, sometimes there's damage to trees that we would rather not see. Sometimes they're not always following those tree protection requirements. And then kind of a surprise one sometimes is impacts to neighboring properties. Whenever we're looking at sites, sometimes we get caught up in just looking at the site that we're on, but... Trees do this funny thing, like sit in your property lines and your roots might go onto the neighboring property. And so if you're building something new, if you're digging up on a site, disturbing a site, we don't want to accidentally harm a neighbor's tree. So kind of pivoting over to what's been more the genesis of this process is the work from Brad Goss. So Brad Goss could be described as an intern with the sustainability community. I would say more accurately, he's a successful attorney that is making a bit of a career pivot. And as part of the education that he was going for, I believe it was the horticulture program through Meramec. He worked with the Sustainability Advisory Committee to take a look at our landscape regulations. It was not directly part of our comprehensive planning process, but there was a lot of overlap in the work that he did. So it was a great point to kind of kick off on the work that we were doing. He evaluated, you know, our current regulations. He compared them to our peer communities in Morton Arboretum, which is kind of the gold standard for tree cultivation, preservation, growth. Identified some inconsistencies and gaps, but probably the most important thing to come out of the work that he did was his focus on keystone species. As a reminder, keystone species is going to be a species of tree that has kind of an outsized impact on the broader ecological environment. If this is something that interests you, these books here on the screen They're books that Brad recommended to us whenever he was working with us. Essentially, the idea is that not all trees are created equal. You might have a tree that supports 10 insects. You might have tree that supports 100 insects, a tree that supports more of insects, birds, whatever it may be. is gonna have a disproportionately greater positive impact on the broader ecological environment because that all feeds into life cycles of different animals, birds, species, pollinators, all that fun stuff. The idea is that if we are intentional about the trees that we plant, we can have a more positive impact on our surrounding environment. kind of give you a quick summary of some proposed changes. So after Brad completed that work, I took some of that information and we in the office started working, okay, what can we pull of the work that he's done that sort of meets our comp plan goals? and is kind of in the direction that we want to go with. So started integrating the work that he did into some revisions. And right now we're working with a landscape consultant that is really familiar with our review process to try to make sure we refine some good revisions and we bring you a good product. But some of the changes that we're looking at, We wanna update our purpose statement, our definitions to reflect new ecological intent, that direction that we're going. There's quite a bit of repetition. There's some definitions that are repeated. There's some calculations that are repeated, plan items repeated. So we wanna make sure we're consolidating where we can. updating our ANSI references. If I recall, that stands for American National Standards Institute and that's kind of your quality standard for a tree and landscape plantings. Getting into some numbers that might be kind of interesting. So increasing our native minimum requirement from a third to two thirds for trees. adding a new minimum requirement that 75% of trees be those keystone species. I'd like to reassure everybody, there are plenty of keystone species. Something awesome that Brad did is that he gave us kind of a revised tree list to start with and we're comparing that to what we have in Public Works and working with our landscape professionals to make sure that that tree list is kind of going in the direction that we want. But there's a ton of keystone species that are available for people to consider. Right now, our tree and landscape regulations suggest that you might consider the use of native plantings on your site, plants that are not trees. And typically people aren't too interested in that one, but there's tons of benefits to Missouri native plantings, especially in a lot of the clay soil that we have here in Clayton. So we're looking at adding maybe a requirement that a third of the plantings on site be required to be Missouri native. Right now, if somebody does not meet the canopy coverage requirements for their site, they are charged a fee. That fee does not seem to be super effective at deterring people from clear cutting their sites or from not meeting those goals. So we wanna look at an adjustment of that. Also, that fee is... you know, based on information that's 10 years old. We've had inflation. We've had updates to the cost of planting new trees. So we want to make sure that fee reflects the actual costs of somebody not planting those trees on their site. We want to look at a lawn alternatives section. So this is kind of something that was inspired a little bit by the Sustainability Advisory Committee, and that's if somebody wants to pursue something that is alternative from the typical grass that you would find on a lawn, is there a way that we can do that that is appropriate, context sensitive, and allows us to have a lot of the benefits that comes with those lawn alternatives? And then most importantly, we want to revise our approved tree lists that reflects all of these changes that we're making. So some of the next steps that we're looking at over the next one to two months, we're gonna be working with our landscape consultant as we continue to refine those revisions that we're looking and then hopefully we can come to you guys with a nice proposed revised landscape section in Q1 of next year. All right, yeah, throw it to you

Speaker 1

guys. Ryan, thank you so much. Does anybody have any questions for Ryan? Yeah, thanks

Speaker 3

Ryan, that was really great. And I just wanted to add too that Brad Goss did make a complete pivot, as you called it, and even has his own company now, Second Nature Landscape Design LLC. And his work was really great in helping with the sustainability committee and otherwise, and even with cool cities and everything else. One thing that came up at planning, at the plan commission when you started on this topic, was if there was a way to not just look at individual lots but in keeping with keeping the character of a neighborhood can we look where a neighborhood is as uh we look for canopy as we look for green space and things like that i don't know how that is done but i don't know if you all have given any more thought approach like that yeah

Speaker 2

so um i think a good place to kind of reflect on that is the recommendations that brad gave us and on i would say on the most progressive end of thought around landscape regulations is the idea of the urban canopy, the urban forest trees, regardless of whether they're on private property, right-of-way and parks, all that fun stuff. Really tracking all of that to think of things at a higher ecological scale. It's really, really hard to do that just kind of at the scale that we were at with the amount of staffing that we have. While, you know, we can collect data on properties over time, we've got some GIS data that we can work with. if we were to get into the direction of regulating at like a neighborhood or citywide level, that's kind of a totally different beast. It's a lot more intent than what we're looking at.

Speaker 3

I know too, that you all were provided some of the model ordinances, you know, from botanical gardens, from different people with the sustainability committee and otherwise. And is that something that you all, are trying to incorporate into or model after, or what's going on

Speaker 2

with that? Yeah, actually, you know, it's, it's great that there's a lot of good model ordinances out there too. There's, there's ones that have been provided by Brad. There's ones provided from folks at sustainability. Our landscape consultant working on this has helped do similar things in other communities. So, you know, while we're, while we're still kind of on the forefront of landscape regulations in Clayton, there's some, you know, great peers that we get to rely on to see what they've done and how effective their work has been.

Speaker 3

Okay. Because something else that came up too, one of the concerns was, you're right, there was concern too that the fee that's charged for reducing canopy or something really didn't seem to be serving the purposes of the city and what to do about that. Another concern is after the construction, if we're only looking at when the construction is happening, what happens afterwards? We met the requirements, we got our approvals, and now we can do whatever we want with our land. Or And maybe that's it, too. How do you handle properties after they've been developed to make sure they continue to meet those goals? So that's something I think that would be good to look at if it takes more staffing. Or I think there's people on the Sustainability Committee. If you wanted to present with them, we'd be happy to jump in with some ideas on what other cities are doing on that. I know it's taking it beyond what you're doing right now, but that may be a next step. Something else was if canopy coverage right now is below and most of our residential areas, what our goals are as a city. And when new construction happens, I think we tend to just say, can you match the canopy that's there now? I wonder if there's a way to incrementally say you're redeveloping this property. Can you move it closer to the canopy that is the goal of the city in the neighborhood? Does that make sense?

Speaker 2

Yeah, and I can actually clarify. So whenever there's basically like a flat rate canopy that's based on your zoning district, and anytime somebody triggers these landscape related regulations, that's what we'd like to hold them to. If somebody doesn't meet those requirements, you know, there's options for people to ask for waivers, but pretty much any example I've seen, they're paying the fee. Okay.

Speaker 4

Okay. I'll pass. Thank you.

Speaker 5

It's got two things. One, part of it's selfish. Either way, can we add at some point when you guys are done with the Keystone species and the native planting, if it's websiteable, it'd be nice to have the list on the website because I am currently searching for Missouri native species and it's hard for me to find where they are. The other question I've got is for new developments in downtown, is there something that we could on some of these changes make to require bigger or more trees and planting on new downtown projects as well? Or is that kind of outside of the scope of where you guys are at?

Speaker 2

It's a little bit outside because what's different about mixed-use commercial properties like in downtown is oftentimes they're developing to their maximum buildable area. The reason it works on residential properties is because they have deep setbacks in the front and rear property where they can place those trees. That's just not the way that our mixed-use zoning is designed. Most of the time, if you've got new trees being planted in a commercial or mixed-use area, they're street trees, which is public works' area. If you do have a tree being planted on a commercial site, I would say that that's something just to be excited about that it happened. I'm like, oh, they're not going to cover the entire site? That's okay. What's... Where do they have space for trees? And that

Speaker 5

makes sense. It's just, I mean, I think everybody knows how stark the difference is when you leave neighborhoods and go to downtown, even with like little tiny street trees. So that's why I was asking if there was a way that we could help encourage or require bigger and more fuller trees so downtown isn't so starkly not shaded. But I get your point. So thanks.

Speaker 6

Just two quick questions. So I think these changes are great. I'm just curious, is there like a follow up within like a year of these projects where we're like seeing all these plantings that we required still alive?

Speaker 2

No, we currently do not have a follow-up process. We're really good about tracking things before, not necessarily after. Basically, when somebody goes through the process of developing a site, we kind of checklist that everything has been constructed how it's supposed to, planned it out as opposed to, but there's no process at the moment for going back a year or two years later to see if those are there.

Speaker 6

Yeah. I think we should probably have one just because if we're requiring all this and it's supposed to do all this work overall, over time, you know, grow in and do all these great things that I think we need to make sure that they're actually it's actually happening. And the other thing is just with like the tree canopy. Do we ever look at like the potential of what a tree is going to be? So like if there are if they are planting new ones, and I'm, you know, a one year old tree is not going to do what a 10 year old tree is that taken into consideration with that?

Speaker 2

Yes, our canopy coverage right now in our approved tree list is based on that tree at maturity. That's where we're currently estimating it. I'd say where you really start to get into the differences in potential is if somebody's taking trees off of a site because as that tree gets older, it gets a lot better at creating canopy. You're not really going to see a lot of the benefit of those trees until they get to be 10, 20 years old. Okay,

Speaker 6

so you are looking at... the future when you're figuring out the tree canopy.

Speaker 2

Yes, but it's different considerations in a tree that you're planting versus a tree that you retain.

Speaker 6

Got it. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Thank you.

Speaker 1

Ryan, thank you very much. Look forward to seeing what happens in first quarter of 2027, you said. So great. Thank you very much. Thank you very All right. We are, we were just for the audience. We were getting an update on our tree and landscape regulations. That was our six 30 discussion session. So it's now seven o'clock. So we will start our seven o'clock meeting. If we could, if city clerk could call the roll.

Speaker 7

Council member abuse here. Council member Patel here. Council member Gary Feder

Council member abuse here. Council member Patel here. Council member Fader

Speaker 1

here.

Speaker 7

Council member Yorg. Council member Waldman here. Council member. I'm sorry. Maylin Smith here. Mayor McAndrew? Here. City Manager David Gipson? Here. City Attorney O'Keefe? Here. Thank you.

Council member Yorg. Council member Waldman here. Council member. I'm sorry. Maylin Smith here. Mayor McAndrew? Here. City Manager Gibson? Here. City Attorney O'Keefe? Here. Thank you.

Speaker 1

The first part of our agenda is called our open forum portion. So if anybody would like to address us on a matter that's not on the agenda, you're welcome to come up now. Otherwise, you'll wait for your agenda item to come up and then there will be an opportunity for comment. And this is just an opportunity to let everyone know that if you do wish to speak on an item, there are speaker cards out in the hall. It just helps our city clerk keep track. So before you come up or at a break, you're welcome to bring the speaker card up. Oh, maybe they're gone. Maybe we need to run some more. Thank you, Peter. Otherwise, we'll figure it out. If they're gone and you haven't figured out a card, we will just be careful to take your name. And that there is also when you come up and address us, there is a three-minute time limit, which our city clerk will keep an eye out on. Okay. Seeing nobody for the open forum portion, we will get started with our regular agenda. The first part of our meeting is our consent agenda. I'll open the discussion. Are there any comments or questions about anything on the consent agenda from the council? Seeing none, Council Member Buse. I move to approve the consent agenda. Second. Any discussion?

Speaker 7

Council Member Buse. Aye. Council Member Patel. Aye. Council member Gary Feder.

Council Member Buse. Aye. Council Member Patel. Aye. Council member Fader.

Speaker 4

Aye.

Speaker 7

Councilmember Walden. Aye. Councilmember Betsy Meyland-Smith. Aye. Mayor McAndrew?

Councilmember Walden. Aye. Councilmember Malin Smith. Aye. Mayor McAndrew?

Speaker 1

Aye. The next item, we don't have any old business, new business. The first item is an extension of our custodial services. Mr. City Manager?

Speaker 8

Yes, the Public Works Department requests approval of the Second Amendment to Custodial Services Contract with Building Stars Incorporated to extend the custodial services at City Hall, the Police Station, Municipal Building and the Municipal Maintenance Facility. The original custodial services contract was approved in March of 2021 as a three-year agreement with two additional three-year extension options upon terms agreeable to both parties. The proposed amendment exercises the second and final three-year extension option, extending the agreement through September 30th, 2029. The proposed three-year extension totals $304,528, which represents an increase of 3.3% over the current amount. Fiscal year 27 budget includes funding for the first year of the extension. Funding for the subsequent years will be included as a part of the annual budget process. City staff recommends approval of the second amendment and authorization for the director of public works to approve change orders not to exceed 10% of the annual contract amount for each fiscal year to address any unforeseen service requirements.

Speaker 1

Thank you. I'll open the discussion. Are there any questions or comments from the council? Any questions or comments from the audience? I will say, I should have mentioned this before. If you're online, you're welcome to raise your hand and you'll be allowed to speak when your turn comes up. Just make sure you raise your hand. And again, the three minute time limit would also pertain to attendees that are online. Seeing no questions from the council or the audience, Council Member Buse.

Speaker 3

I introduce Bill No. 7184, approving a contract extension with Building Stars Incorporated for custodial services to be read for the first time by title only.

Speaker 1

Second. Any discussion? Mr. City Attorney.

Speaker 9

Bill number 7184, first reading, an ordinance approving the second contract extension with Building Stars Incorporated for custodial services at City Hall, the Police Station Municipal Building, and the Municipal Maintenance Facility.

Speaker 1

All those in favor? Aye.

Speaker 3

Any opposed? Councilmember Buse? I move that the council give unanimous consent to consideration for adoption of bill number 7184 on the day of its introduction. Second.

Speaker 1

All those in Any opposed? The vote passes 7-0. Let the minutes reflect that the council has given unanimous consent. I'm sorry, 6-0.

Speaker 3

I introduce Bill No. 7184, approving a contract extension with Building Stars Incorporated for custodial services to be read for the second time by title only. Second.

Speaker 1

Any discussion? Mr. City Attorney.

Speaker 9

Bill number 7184, second reading and consideration for adoption. An ordinance approving the second contract extension with Building Stars Incorporated for custodial services at City Hall, the Police Station Municipal Building, and the Municipal Maintenance Facility.

Speaker 7

Council Member Buse? Aye. Council Member Patel? Aye. Council member Gary Feder?

Council Member Buse? Aye. Council Member Patel? Aye. Council member Fader?

Speaker 9

Aye.

Speaker 7

Councilmember Waldron? Aye. Councilmember Betsy Meyland-Smith? Aye. Mayor McAndrew? Aye.

Councilmember Waldron? Aye. Councilmember Malin-Smith? Aye. Mayor McAndrew? Aye.

Speaker 1

Thank you. The next item on our agenda is a contract to begin the Widown Median Restoration.

Speaker 8

Yes, the Public Works Department is requesting approval of a construction contract for the Widown Boulevard Median Restoration Project. The work includes restoration and reconstruction of Widown Boulevard medians, including site demolition and removals, protection of existing trees and improvements, grading and soil preparation, planning, turf, irrigation, site lighting, concrete, and related work for a complete installation. Bids were opened on October 23rd, 2026 and only one bid was received. The bid was submitted by the Vision Civil Construction LLC and the original base bid amount of $2,055,484.55. During staff's review of the bid schedule, a few errors involving units of measurement and quantities were identified. The errors were reviewed by the contractor and engineer, and a corrected bid schedule was prepared to reflect the intended units and quantities. The contractor provided revised unit pricing, and the resulting revised bid amount is $1,791,621.75. Staff has reviewed the corrected bid schedule, the supporting documentation, checked local references, and determined that Vision Civil Construction LLC is a responsible and qualified bidder. The proposed contract amount again is $1.791 million, and we recommend a construction contingency of $180,000 for unforeseen conditions and authorized changes, resulting in a total authorization not to exceed $1,971,621.75. The contract requires the work to commence within 10 days after issuance of the written notice to proceed. and to be completed within 275 consecutive calendar days. Early reestablishment of roadway lighting is a critical priority project. Funding for the project is available in the Capital Improvement Fund, and the City will seek reimbursement from the Federal Emergency Management Agency and the State Emergency Management Agency for eligible project costs subject to final eligibility determinations and documentation requirements. Staff recommends approval of the project.

Speaker 1

Thank you. I'll open the discussion for the audience. This is a project to really take care of that part of Y down that was damaged or significantly damaged during the tornado. So I will open the discussion. Are there any questions or comments from the council? My only

Speaker 3

comments are, I very much appreciate the careful work and the accountability in documenting everything for the reimbursements that we'd be able to get for this work and the quality of the work that will be done. So it's a little concerning when only one bid is received, but it sounds like staff checked into the qualifications and reputation of the company. So that all sounds good. And I think like with everybody else, I think we're all anxious for this to start happening.

Speaker 10

Thanks, Susan. I am curious. I We usually don't expect one bid, I don't think. Is there something about the nature of this work that we think resulted in that?

Speaker 8

Not necessarily. We thought there would be more bidders. Our engineers thought there would be bidders as well. We had a lot of interest in the pre-bid information that we had put out, so we certainly expected more than one. Unfortunately, that was all we got, and it was within the budgeted amount that And again, upon those reference checks, it's a good contractor. The subs are extremely reputable. So we're comfortable with the vendor we have.

Speaker 10

Thanks. I'm looking at the project plan on the back, the Gantt chart schedule. I'm most interested in understanding when trees will be planted and when lights will be on. And so I'm trying to understand like in December there's tree protection measures installed, but I don't know.

Speaker 8

That's correct. Those are going to be for the existing trees that are out there. Let me pull this up really quickly here.

Speaker 10

Cause then there's plantings, but there's just like one thing of plantings from May to August. And I know when we, as we've talked through this, I think I was expecting tree planting to happen in the winter and Or whenever, because that's when arborists say you should plant trees, I believe. We've been told that repeatedly and we've told our residents that repeatedly. And then that the other plantings would come in like at the end of the project. So what can you say to clarify? I know on

Speaker 8

the tree portion of it, trees are included in their planting timeline. Now- Our arborist that we have through our contract with LJC, the engineer on the project, is talking with our staff and with the contractor to figure that out. But if you look at the timeline itself, it's going to be very difficult to get trees in much sooner because you have the tree protection that we're talking about. That's just protecting the existing trees on the site. Um, then you have to remove the existing improvements. Uh, we have the electric rough in for the street lights, um, that needs to go in the street lights are really taking the priority as far as the first things to go on the ground. Um, because we we've got to get those up. Uh, we then have a rough grading that takes place. Uh, that's through the end of February. Uh, then the irrigation rough in that's in March, uh, the electric pulling wire, um, for the street lights so that we can get those installed. Uh, we're looking at that to happen, uh, um in late april or by late april then you have some soil amendments and some other things before we can get the trees in the ground so we're really working with the arborist to see what we can do as far as planting to potentially speed up the trees but i don't have an answer for you exactly tonight so we'll provide more updates as we have those conversations but the way this timeline is falling the tree planting typically wouldn't take place until later in this project um if that pushes it into a time of year where it's not favorable then we need to have a conversation about when that takes place yeah

Speaker 10

okay

Speaker 8

it's just hard to get the trees in the ground before the electric is actually in we've gone in and graded everything and and have done the store the uh the soil amendments

Speaker 10

yeah so um i just want to say like it seems like that means we might not have trees until the next winter. And if that's what we have to do to make sure that we get trees that are going to last for another hundred years, then it is what it is. But it's, I mean, I'm sure as someone who lives right there, it's really frustrating. And I'm trying to understand when we can actually expect lights to be on. And it seems like it's April or May. Is that, am I reading that right? Site electric install fixtures, pull wire termination. That

Speaker 8

is correct.

Speaker 10

April.

Speaker 8

Yes. And those lights have been ordered because we had the extended lead time of 16 weeks on those. Yeah. So we've done everything we can to cut the lead time down and then we're just going to be working through the project. Once we get the electric pulled and the improvements there ready, then we should be ready to install the lights at that point. So we're looking at spring.

Speaker 4

A couple of questions regarding reimbursement. So it's my understanding since the tornado, we've been working with FEMA to seek reimbursement and we've been teeing up that process for a long time. And that the basic distinction is that in the Y down median, that everything that was essentially not tree planting could be subject to reimbursement. So I guess I'm wondering, first of all, just to clarify that this particular project is about everything other than tree planting. It's basically doing everything necessary prior to the tree planting, and it is covered, at least we hope, by FEMA reimbursement.

Speaker 8

Not necessarily. So in this particular case, what FEMA is going to reimburse will be the cost for the streetlights and the cost for the irrigation. So those types of assets, they'll reimburse. They will not reimburse for grading soil amendments. Those are large parts of the cost here, along with all of the plantings on the site, not just the trees, but the lower ground cover as well. So in this The bid tabs themselves of the roughly $1.8 million in costs on this project, the FEMA eligible items are somewhere around 421,000 of that total amount, which is about 23%. We would expect to get an 85% reimbursement of that 421,000, which is about 357,000. So on a $1.8-million project, roughly we expect to get about $357,000 back. That being said, there is an effort underway with CCF. I know that they are trying to raise funds to help offset costs for planting and I know do some additional art installations and things. So our hope is between the FEMA reimbursement and the privately raised funds through CCF that it covers a large portion of this project.

Speaker 4

And I assume reimbursement or the effort with FEMA on this particular project was really not possible until we had a specific contract in hand for them to review. Is

Speaker 8

that accurate? This will be a true reimbursement where they are going to reimburse our costs. They won't forward fund any of this, but we had to go through their steps to get the project approved before we could even bid this and get it moving. Thank you.

Speaker 6

Just a quick question, just since we only had one bid. I mean, is this company, have they done work in Clayton before or projects of this scale that

Speaker 8

we... We haven't come across anyone in all of our reference checks that had any concerns with them. And again, they're subs. It's Gerstner Electric for the streetlights. We use them on a regular basis. They've installed most of the lights that we've put in in the last 20 years. Cold grading is involved with the grading and site work. They're an extremely reputable firm. So we have a really good group of contractors here, so we're comfortable with it. Great. Thank you. And I would say to re-bid it too, we would lose another two months in the whole process advertising it and doing all that. So this is within budget parameters with good contractors. We really want to get moving. Right. Thank you.

Speaker 11

Yeah. I want to echo Becky's concerns about the timeline. I think they're I feel like maybe there's been some miscommunication at some point because I feel like we have been telling residents in Ward 1 that lights are coming in January. And I don't know that we meant ever to say like the lights will arrive to a warehouse someplace in January. We, I think, meant they would. be lit. So I'm frustrated by that, but I also appreciate the specific call out in the ordinance of the prioritization of the roadway lighting. So I know that you have heard us and heard the residents of Ward 1 specifically about the lighting. I wonder as we work through this process, I understand. I mean, seeing it all laid out like this, like you can totally understand the sequence of events. And also I wonder if we could try really, really hard to have lights on, even if it's not all at once, like if we could incrementally light things as we, you know, I mean, as one goes up, if we could turn it on, that would just bring a lot of joy to people.

Speaker 8

And we've had that conversation. One thing I will say about this timeline is this is what they included with their bid package. We haven't issued the notice to proceed yet. We haven't sat down to have our kickoff meeting where we're going to go through this whole, it's really a Gantt chart with a bunch of dates on it. um, to try to figure all of this out. And again, with the tree planning, if we're not comfortable with the tree planning timeline and trying to put things in the ground, uh, you know, late spring, early summer, um, then, then we're going to wait if we need to, uh, we want to make sure that what we put in the ground lives and is going to be viable. So, uh, There's some work to be done still on this timeline. We'll provide updates as that goes. The other thing that we should have soon is just an update on our order overall with the streetlights where we try to order that stuff in advance to see if we're still on that 16-week timeline or if there's any way to get those any sooner. If so, then we'll try to work it into this schedule here. So more to come on that. This is just what they submitted with their proposal, and we still need to work through some things. But we're absolutely prioritizing the lights there, and as soon as we can get things lit, we will.

Speaker 11

Okay. I also, I haven't checked the website lately, but the timeline on the website for the tornado recovery is, has...

Speaker 8

We had that conversation this week too. Now that we have this in hand, we have a better timeline there. We have a better timeline on street lighting overall. We're comfortable putting up an update. We didn't want to do it until we had a chance to talk to a contractor and got a better sense of when things will actually be happening. So as soon as we have that information, we'll be ready to go with an update. We've had that conversation with communications this week. Okay. Thank you.

Speaker 11

That's all.

Speaker 1

Thank you. Are there any questions or comments from the audience? Any questions or comments online? Um, thanks for, um, thank you for all the questions. Um, I mean, I echo all of you that I just certainly look forward to getting this off the ground. Um, if there was no other questions or comments, uh, council member abuse.

Speaker 3

I introduced bill number 7, 1 8 5, approving a contract with vision civil construction LLC for the Y down median restoration construction project to be read for the first time by title only. Second. Any discussion?

Speaker 1

Mr. City Attorney.

Speaker 9

Bill number 7185, first reading an ordinance approving a construction contract with Vision Civil Construction LLC for the Y-Down Boulevard median restoration project.

Speaker 1

All those in favor? Aye.

Speaker 3

Any opposed? Council Member Buse? I move that the council give unanimous consent to consideration for adoption of bill number 7185 on the day of its introduction. Second.

Speaker 1

All those in Aye. Any opposed? The vote passes 7-0, 6-0. Let the minutes reflect. The council has given unanimous consent.

Speaker 3

I introduce bill number 7185, approving a contract with Vision Civil Construction LLC for the Yedon Median Restoration Construction Project to be read for the second time by title only. Second. Any discussion?

Speaker 1

Mr. City Attorney.

Speaker 9

Bill number 7185, second reading and consideration for adoption. An ordinance approving a construction contract with Vision Civil Construction LLC for the Y-Down Boulevard Median Restoration Project.

Speaker 7

Council Member Buse? Aye. Council Member Patel? Aye. Council member Gary Feder?

Council Member Buse? Aye. Council Member Patel? Aye. Council member Fader?

Speaker 12

Aye.

Speaker 7

Councilmember Waldman? Aye. Councilmember Betsy Meyland-Smith? Aye. Mayor McAndrew?

Councilmember Waldman? Aye. Councilmember Malin-Smith? Aye. Mayor McAndrew?

Speaker 1

Aye. Thank

Speaker 7

you.

Speaker 1

The next item on our agenda is adding Shrewsbury to our fire training facility. If all of you don't know, we co-own a fire training facility over in Shrewsbury and we co-own it, but then we let a lot of other entities train there. Mr. City Manager.

Speaker 8

Yes, the central core cities Brentwood, Clayton, Richmond Heights and Maplewood collectively operate the Central Core Fire Training Division or CCTD. It's a regional collaboration established to provide consistent high caliber fire service training across participating jurisdictions. The city of Shrewsbury requests to renew the governmental agreement with CCTD for fire training. Program costs within CCTD are assessed on a per firefighter basis and reflect the instructional services training time and administrative support required to deliver the plan and curriculum. For 2027, the participation cost for the Shrewsbury Fire Department is $1,160 per firefighter for a total program amount of $22,040. This includes the established fee associated with the use of the training tower. This intergovernmental agreement transitions training partner municipalities from a one-year agreement to a three-year renewable agreement, providing greater continuity and long-term planning for the Central Corps Fire Training Division. The agreement includes a 5% annual cost increase during the three-year term to account for increasing operational and training expenses. Staff recommends approval.

Speaker 1

Thank you. I will open the discussion. Are there any questions or comments from the Council?

Speaker 3

Just to say that, you know, again, that I certainly appreciate The collaboration with our neighbors, it's fiscally responsible and certainly contributes to excellence in the region.

Speaker 10

One question, is Shrewsbury part of our fire authority study?

Speaker 8

Yes, they are participating.

Speaker 10

Thanks.

Speaker 8

No questions.

Speaker 1

Any questions or comments from the audience or online? Seeing none, Council Member Buse.

Speaker 3

I introduce Bill No. 7186, approving the Intergovernmental Agreement for the Central Corps Fire Training Division for the City of Shrewsbury to be read for the first time by title only.

Speaker 1

Second. Any discussion? Mr. City Attorney.

Speaker 9

Bill number 7186, first reading. An ordinance authorizing the mayor to execute an intergovernmental agreement on behalf of the city of Clayton, Missouri, with the cities of Brentwood, Richmond Heights, Maplewood, and Shrewsbury for battalion chief training officer to provide coordinated fire training services.

Speaker 1

All those in favor?

Speaker 3

Aye.

Speaker 1

Any

Speaker 3

opposed? I move that the council give unanimous consent to consideration for adoption of bill number 7186 on the day of its introduction. Second.

Speaker 1

All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? The vote passes 6-0. Let the minutes reflect that the Council has given unanimous consent. I move to

Speaker 3

introduce Bill No. 7186, approving the Intergovernmental Agreement for the Central Corps Fire Training Division for the City of Shrewsbury to be read for the second time by title only. Second. Any

Speaker 1

discussion? Mr. City Attorney.

Speaker 9

Bill number 7186, second reading in consideration for adoption. An ordinance authorizing the mayor to execute an intergovernmental agreement on behalf of the city of Clayton, Missouri, with the cities of Brentwood, Richmond Heights, Maplewood, and Shrewsbury, for a battalion chief training officer to provide coordinated fire training services.

Speaker 7

Council Member Buse. Aye. Council Member Patel. Aye. Council member Gary Feder.

Council Member Buse. Aye. Council Member Patel. Aye. Council member Fader.

Speaker 9

Aye.

Speaker 7

Councilmember Waldman. Aye. Councilmember Betsy Meyland-Smith. Aye. Mayor McAndrew. Aye.

Councilmember Waldman. Aye. Councilmember Malin-Smith. Aye. Mayor McAndrew. Aye.

Speaker 1

All right, the last item on our agenda is a continued discussion of our ALPR policy, which I think many of you are here to listen to and perhaps comment on. I think procedurally or just kind of how it's going to go, I think as a council, I think we're going to continue to have a discussion up here. I would... you know I'd rather rather than listen to your comment now I think it would be just appropriate for us to kind of talk about things maybe potential amendments to the policy as we've thought more about it we've certainly appreciated everybody's comments I know we've gotten a lot of emails I know we've had a lot of conversations with residents which we sincerely appreciate so I think we'll have some discussion up here and then there will be certainly time for public comment So kind of given that, I'll just ask if there's any member of the council that would kind of like to get this discussion started, thinking about how there might be ways to amend the policy in front of us, looking at perhaps some broader sharing with some appropriate controls.

Speaker 10

Thank you, Mayor. Yeah. So what we have before us today was developed following our last meeting two weeks ago. And many of you were there or probably have followed up and maybe watched the exciting video to see how the discussion went. But at the end of that time, we ended. and gave direction to the staff that we wanted to look at limiting direct access to our surveillance data to agencies in St. Louis County and agencies that do not participate in a 287G agreement, which means they cooperate with ICE. And so that's what's before us today and really appreciate the way staff drafted it and prepared it for us so that we could consider it. And over the last two weeks, we've heard from many residents sharing a variety of perspectives and concerns around all parts of this issue. And I know I personally have continued to reflect on what are the risks that that we are trying to mitigate? And how can we balance that with the benefits that we have seen from the use of this technology? And so tonight, I will propose that we expand upon the two criteria in what's before us that define an eligible law enforcement agency. And so Section 4 The policy defines an eligible law enforcement agency as one that is permitted this direct access to our data through their searching system. And And so there's two criteria there today, geography and policy. And I will propose that we expand on both. I will propose that the geography from St. Louis County to the major case squad counties. And I will continue the exclusion of agencies with 287 agreements, and then add two additional criteria that we are able to verify that I believe demonstrate an agency manages their use of surveillance technology in a way that is consistent with the best practices that are outlined in the governor's executive order from September and our own internal policies. And those two criteria I propose we add are that the agency is an accredited agency and that the agency has filed a certificate of compliance with the executive order with the Missouri State Department of Public Safety. And obviously, we'll be discussing this more, finding out what we all think, and staff will advise us on precisely how those things criteria should be worded before we propose any particular amendment language.

Speaker 3

Yeah. Let me say first how much I appreciate all the input we've gotten, because this is a huge issue and we have to make an informed decision. There's not going to be a decision that's perfect, because quite honestly, flock isn't perfect. the whole firestorm across the country with flock. It came in as kind of a sleepy camera surveillance. And then, um, as, as there were abuses and misuses and use for immigration and reproductive rights and all these things, it got more in the spotlight that it was a, um, private company that is getting huge investments with private equity and venture capital funds. And what does it sell? It's, you know, contracts with individual, with municipalities. What it's real asset probably is a national surveillance system. So those are real, real concerns that we have to stay aware of all this time. The other side of that, it does help. It is a very effective law enforcement tool. So how do we balance these principles that we have? You know, innocent until proven guilty, value of privacy and all these things. with the fact that Flock is out there, as are other companies like Flock, and they are helpful to law enforcement. So what do we do? The big issue of whether or not to continue in Flock, I think after all the discussions this council has had, I don't think we're at a point where we would have consensus on not continuing that contract. So then, given that, I think we have to continue to stay aware of it, continue to get information on our own and from our community. We're simply your voices. So if we're going to continue with block, I see it breaking down into two different areas. One is to make sure that we only collect the data that is actually useful to our law enforcement, correct collection of data, and From the beginning, Chief Smith has told us that our cameras are just what we need. There are a limited number of cameras just around the perimeter of our city that feed data into Flock. Now, remember, we may own the data, but it's Flock's cloud. So take that for what it is. We're feeding into that company's system, but we have a very limited, we're collecting limited data One of the comments from a new resident was that one of the cameras does focus on one of our elementary schools, and we may want to reconsider the positioning of that versus having pictures of families coming and going every single day. And that's something that we can certainly ask our police department to look at. But as far as the collection of data, it seems that we are limiting our collection to its particular purpose. The second part then is How do we share that data, how do we manage it, and this is where I think we have to talk as a console and come to an agreement, and this is what becky was just addressing. This is first I want to make clear we're not talking it's never come up that we wouldn't cooperate with neighboring jurisdictions traditional police activity is there's a case there's a matter you call your neighbor you call across the state and say. What's going on? You get the information. You have a personal contact. It's just not, it's simply not an open door to our internal files and investigation. It's actually calling and then a cooperation together. Flock is a different beast. It's a private company with private community data that, again, because it's their data, a neighboring jurisdiction can go straight and get that without us knowing it if we give them permission to open that door. So do you want an open door to our data with other districts? And if so, who or do you want them to have to knock and then start working with us? That's really the question we're talking about. It's not it's a unique situation, expanding access, not cutting off existing cooperation. I was comfortable with the. With the withdrawing that limit on St. Louis County because we are part of St. Louis County and. It seemed like a reasonable place to go as FLOC continues to develop. As there's been outcry, and to protect its profit, FLOC has put in more and more safeguards, and that's good. And that's because of people like all of us noticing the issues and trying to deal with it. I know that there is concern that we continue to share it with the counties that are part of the major case squad. We already share with the major case squad, there was some confusion on that too. So do we expand it to those additional six counties to allow that open-door access to our data without us even knowing it. I'm still a little uncomfortable with going that far at this point. This is a fluid discussion as FWOC continues to change, as the data continues to change. If that's where the Council ends up going today, you know, I can go along with that, but I think the more we restrict it to the actual need to expand, the better it is. Again, remembering this isn't cutting off cooperation. It's limiting and expanded access. So I would like to hear what everyone else says to see where we come out on this, but that's where I am right now.

Speaker 4

Well, I certainly think it's a good idea that the council is putting out a policy. I think the police department has had a policy relating to... license plate readers for quite a while. And frankly, I don't think we give the police department enough credit for how much effort they have made to achieve this balance between data protection and the safety of our community. To get out of the way quickly, I agree with the bar on 287G entities from this information. You know, I think clearly the elephant in the room tonight is obviously this provision in the draft policy under the heading of interagency data sharing. And as we've already talked about what it said, it was drafted two weeks ago, was that automatic access to the city's ALPR system would be limited to law enforcement agencies located within St. Louis County. A few meetings back, Chief Smith provided numbers on ALPR network searches. The Clayton Police Department, as I think we all know, uses the flock safety camera, the ALPR system currently on a statewide Missouri basis. Some council members were concerned about the volume of searches statewide and wondered how that number could be substantially reduced. Chief Smith was asked to provide some geographic alternatives, and he did subsequently provide three alternatives. The chief was not specifically recommending any of them. He indicated, however, that the alternatives would produce a significantly reduced number of searches. And to be clear, as far as I know, the chief still clearly believes that the statewide Missouri system currently used by Clayton is the preferred system. But nonetheless, he was responding to the council's request. We should keep in mind that the state of Missouri has 114 counties, 115 if you count the city of St. Louis, which is a city and a county. But the city presented, the chief presented three geographical alternatives. We know one was a St. Louis County only. One was St. Louis, St. Charles, Jefferson and Franklin. And the third was already referenced above. It's the four counties plus two others, Lincoln and Warren. all of which in total, those six are members of the major case squad of Greater St. Louis, which we all know work together to investigate major crimes. So at the end of our last meeting, which was lengthy and somewhat contentious on October 27th, with a lot of items still left on the agenda, a majority of the council asked the staff to prepare this policy with the St. Louis County only alternative. I'm happy to say in the two weeks since that meeting, we as council members have talked a great deal to each other, to the chief, and we've heard from a large number of residents, a number are here tonight regarding their specific concerns and recommendations today. And I applaud all of them who have contacted us because I think it it has made a big difference. It appears, given all this input that a vote on this policy tonight will at least have a significant amendment to that part of the policy regarding interagency data sharing. My perspective on all this is. What is best for the city of Clayton? What is best for its residents and the large number of people who come to Clayton from various parts of our region to work in our city? Most importantly, what keeps our community safe and allows our first class police department to do so with maximum effectiveness? I'm certainly aware that ALPR raises concern about data protection and to the credit of both the council and particularly credit to the Clayton Police Department, much has been done in this area I don't have to go into a lot of detail, but even prior to the prior meeting, requirements that all ALPR database searches needed to be tied to a valid department report number so to allow for adequate audit. A shortened data retention period of seven days, considerably less than even what the governor has requested, which was 30 days. restrictions on which personnel within the Clayton Police Department can access the database, and automatic rejection. I believe they're referred to as immigration blockers in our system so that any request that indicates an interest from another community, another police department on an immigration matter is automatically not responded to. And then finally, as has been talked about at the council level consistently, a rejection of the 287G immigration enforcement program with ICE and DHS. And I'm certainly happy that that's not being formalized in this document. Again, at the last meeting, in addition to those items, the chief talked about adding strategic placement of all of our cameras, that there would be no additional cameras in Clayton without specific council approval. and that any unauthorized internet use by anyone in our staff would be subject to disciplinary action under city and police department regulations. All that might, in fact, be enforced in the state legislature, I believe, in this session to try to make much more strict the penalties for this kind of action. So given this backdrop, I felt it's essential then to focus on the part of this issue which we don't seem to talk very much about. We justifiably talk about access of other people to our data, but I'm equally interested in what happens to our safety, the safety of our personnel, what keeps us safe and allows our police department to do its job with maximum effectiveness. I believe the current statewide model addresses these objectives by allowing our police department and others to move quickly and effectively in dealing with serious crime. I think simply stated, the broader the net, the better in the state of Missouri. A number of people who have sent us emails have said, for example, hey, when someone commits a crime in the St. Louis area, in two or three hours they can be on the other side of the state of Missouri So this is a concern. Our police department has focused on Missouri statewide only, doesn't address Illinois because it turns out most of the, even though flock is extremely popular and widely used in Missouri in Illinois, other safety cameras are widely used. And there are a number of other manufacturers that, uh, that use those city of St. Louis has not impacted it by this because they, again, you are not part of the flock system. They, they use other kinds of, um, uh, cameras, um, Gentech, Axon, Motorola, um, So what happens here as I understand it in Clayton is if a license plate is read in Clayton and triggers a match with the flock database linking the plate to an unresolved criminal act outside of Clayton, or if an unsolved crime that occurs in Clayton includes the license plate of the perpetrator, our Clayton Police Department can initiate currently a statewide search of the plate. This potential sharing of the plate can move quickly and effectively. Time is of the essence, and a suspect can within an hour or two have traveled far and wide. And so I at least believe that it is critical that the current system we have that is statewide stays in place. I conclude that seeking a balance between data protection and maximizing public safety relies considerably on the continuation of the Missouri statewide model, and that that's what we should be supporting. I realize there are concerns about the number of statewide searches reported in the audit system. However, I would keep in mind that these are very narrowly focused, fully documented, electronic-only searches of license plates. It's not a search of anything else in our data. It's limited to license plates. If the council wants to drop the statewide Missouri sharing model solely to reduce the number of sharing agencies and related searches, the numbers provided by this chief indicated that any of these three alternatives would accomplish that. I will say that I think the six county sharing model, the major case squad model is clearly the best of these three alternatives. I would say that in the sense that I think it's the least damaging to our Clayton use of the ALPR system, which is after all built around sharing. It is regional in nature. That's six county proposal. And again, the fact that the six counties are part of the major case squad makes some sense about that. So I think it's a step in the right direction. I just don't think it's where we finally should be winding up. I believe ultimately the statewide Missouri model can be maintained while modified by simply deleting automatic access to 287 participants. And again, that's a deletion that I would understand and completely support. I would keep in mind that I've talked to the chief about this, that if we simply eliminated the 287 entities, although there apparently, at least as of yesterday, was not an absolute exact number because you'd have to be talking about the agencies that are both 287C and are part of the program. that they all are included in this particular system, you would still probably drop at least 50 agencies from the total of searches if all you did was eliminate two ADC agencies. The policy that is labeled case-by-case sharing could be revised easily and accordingly. It would eliminate the 287 agencies. It would greatly reduce the number of searches and search agencies. I would say, by the way, that the proposal that Becky has suggested, Council Member Patel, I have no problem with at all. I think that the idea of verifying that people we share with are accredited, that's an objective standard. I think verifying that entities we are sharing with are certified and that they have certified essentially that they will at least abide by the governor's policy. I think those are sensible. So it's, As was suggested, if we are talking about essentially sort of a policy criteria and a geographic criteria, I think the policy makes sense. It also obviously makes sense to eliminate 287G entities. All of those are objective standards. The one that doesn't make sense is this geographic notion. Yeah, six counties is better than four and better than one, but it's not statewide. And I am concerned about the 114 counties that we are about to eliminate from coverage. And my concern is this. If the word, first of all, as far as I know, we're going to be the first ones to take this statewide system and now put some limits on it. We're going to say that from now on, we're only going to deal with six counties instead of statewide. I wonder what's going to happen with the rest of the state. Are they not looking at what we're doing? Would they not say, well, if Clayton thinks we should just cut out the rest of the state, well, maybe up north, out west in the state, maybe we don't need to include Clayton. Now, again, I understand people may say, well, that's not going to happen. Well, the risk is what if it does? I think it is a significant risk. It greatly hurts our ability. And again, that to me is the ultimate question. What is the ability of the Clayton Police Department the next time there is a serious crime in our community to make a search that is effective, that is timely? when we cut out the rest of the state, leaving aside what it says about us as a regional partner. And again, all we've accomplished if we do that is simply reduce the number of searches and search agencies. We haven't done anything in terms of the quality of these. That's what we're doing with accreditation and certificates. So again, this is just a geographic elimination.

Speaker 1

Gary, maybe like at this point, I'm wondering, Chief, if you're able, you know, there was a question about how many right now in the six county area, which includes our major case squad, just because I'm trying to address the amendment that Councilmember Patel has talked about. So if we – there are currently, I believe, 58 agencies, 58 authorized agencies, organizations that are part of our six-county region. Do you have any – I know that you asked the state to provide us with – because they collect as part of this executive order, which really outlines all the different requirements that we hope to see auditing. But as everybody knows, an executive order is not – it's not law. So – As part of the executive order, the governor asked each agency that was going to comply with the order as they shared to send in a certificate. So were you able to find out how many of those agencies or even of the 58 that are that, you know, of our six county region, how many of those have sent in? I

Speaker 13

have not. So the list just came in from the Department of Public Safety this afternoon. So I wasn't able to compare it to our list yet.

Speaker 1

Okay. And then I guess I'm also wondering just in terms of the accredited agencies, do you know how many of those? So

Speaker 13

that was something that came up last night.

Speaker 1

Yeah,

Speaker 13

I understand. Something I would be able to do. It might take a few days, but.

Speaker 1

But do you have a sense that, I mean, I was glancing a little bit at the list with our city manager. It seems like there is a high percentage of entities that are accredited and that are also have sent in a certificate, meaning they're auditing, they're doing all the things that governor is asking police agencies with ALPR cameras to do.

Speaker 13

So like in St. Louis County, we're members of the St. Louis Area Police Chiefs Association. And to be a member of that association, the agency has to be accredited through either through CALEA or through the Missouri Police Chiefs Association So you're going to find most of the municipalities in St. Louis county are accredited. As well as St. Charles County, because they were members of the St. Louis Area Police Chiefs Association. So I would imagine most of them are going to be accredited. When you get out into rural areas, you know, to be accredited is it takes a lot of resources. You know, we almost have a full time job keeping up with the 487 standards, I believe it is that we have to maintain for accreditation. So we have somebody who's our accountability manager. So not every agency has a resource to provide that, you know, that personnel for it. So they, they don't, uh, they may not be interested in doing accreditation for that very reason. Um, but I would imagine most, most agencies within this region are accredited.

Speaker 1

Um, and then probably not all agencies that aren't accredited actually have LPR cameras too, I suppose.

Speaker 13

That's right. So right now, um, there, there, um, There's hundreds of agencies in the state of Missouri, 600 law enforcement agencies, something around there. And we share currently our flock data with about 200 agencies. So not every agency has either flock LPRs or LPRs in general. Like you're going to get a lot of small rural towns that don't find a need for it. Right,

Speaker 1

right. Or entire counties like the city of St. Louis, which does not have flock cameras. They have their own system that is a closed system that they've been using for- 20 years?

Speaker 13

At least 10 years. Okay,

Speaker 1

thank you. I was just curious. I know that we were kind of thinking about that data and I think it certainly to me is impactful for the amendment that Council Member Patel has talked about. So I don't know if anybody else has any questions or comments for Chief or sorry to jump in. I just felt like that sort of information was important to me to hear as we continue to talk about this.

Speaker 4

When would you have information on the accreditation or the certificate

Speaker 13

stipulation? Yeah, I could. I mean, I probably could figure that out within a week.

Speaker 10

I wouldn't suggest like I don't need to know which ones it is in order to like. make the policy.

Speaker 1

Okay,

Speaker 10

right. Like, I just want to be clear about that. Well, I and I, for me, it was I mean,

Speaker 1

yeah, it was kind of this understanding, like, I mean, we've sent it in, but I wanted to understand, was it a common practice of every other agency? Did they think it was something important to send in? Because I think if you're verifying to the governor, I am auditing, I am only doing this for law enforcement purposes. I am I mean, there's a number of things that you're requiring accountability measures, that you're prohibiting the integration of AI facial recognition, like important things that, you know, I think should probably be part of any policy. Yeah,

Speaker 13

if they don't comply with that, they risk losing grant money.

Speaker 1

Right.

Speaker 13

So...

Speaker 8

And just looking at this really quickly, there's probably 25 cities listed on each page and there's 11 pages of cities. So I think just about everybody submitted the form at this point. I think the bigger question is the accreditation part. Anybody with ALPRs has pretty much submitted the form from what I'm looking at here. There's probably a few exceptions, but not many.

Speaker 3

Is this one clarification? If there's a vehicle that's on the hot list and it comes through Clayton, Are you notified that regardless of what your agreement is with

Speaker 13

others? Yeah, because it will be put into a law enforcement database, whether it's NCIC, the National Criminal Information Center, or through another Regis-affiliated database. And as long – because our cameras are connected to the Regis system, so as long as it's put into one of those databases, it's going to give us a hit.

Speaker 10

Yeah, so just to be clear, because it took me a minute to understand this. The hot list is not a piece of the flock system. It is a regional database of law enforcement agencies outside of that. So, like, people don't have to be in flock to know what we put on the hot list or to put something on the hot list that we have visibility of. So I just want to make that clear like it isn't a limiting factor,

Speaker 13

and you could and you could also just clarify to, we could also add vehicles to that hot list, even though they're not maybe not being the database there's been a couple instances where that was helpful for us. Okay, but yeah, thanks.

Speaker 4

Chief, can I clarify? So with our current system, our statewide system, automatically any of the entities that are otherwise eligible can simply electronically determine if there's a link between something they've discovered. They don't have to make any other contact. There's no one in our police department that has to respond. In some ways, this is all done electronically.

Speaker 13

That's right. And if you remember when I showed you the data, a vast majority of those searches of our network are um of a specific plate so if they're looking for a specific plate they can search that and it would it would search our network and if if that plate didn't hit any of our cameras they wouldn't get a return from us but yeah they could um but yeah they can search that automatically the

Speaker 4

secondary provision uh here says essentially i i gather we're going to change it, but whatever the regional restriction is, it then goes on to say that essentially if you're not within our region or you're otherwise prohibited from automatic access, that there's another way to get the information. And I think the suggestion was said earlier that that's not all that difficult. You can get on the phone and And so I understand what the provision seems to say now. And if it was adopted, it's the six counties and that's it. Then if you're a 287 agency, you've been taken off our automatic system. In addition to which, if you're anywhere outside of those six counties, you're also off the automatic list. But the saving grace is supposed to be that any of those folks, even though they can't get the information electronically, they can always call you up And and try it. And I think the theory is that that would make us feel better because they'd have to talk to you and say, hey, I got this plate. That strikes me as being horribly cumbersome and not going to happen. And the whole efficiency of the system breaks down when in these hundred and fourteen other counties. They don't get the information electorate. It doesn't bother me as much with the 287G agencies. I'm okay with their taking the extra step. But for everybody else, it seems to me it creates a terrible burden and really undermines the

Speaker 13

system. So yeah, and since we restricted who can access our system internally, so if somebody called during normal business hours, we have multiple people, investigators on who could produce that search. If it happens during nights or weekends, that's going to be, you know, we may only have one supervisor who has access to the system to search it. So that could limit the efficiency of it. I guess the other thing would be if everybody takes this stance and you had to call multiple agencies, that would become cumbersome to conduct a search.

Speaker 10

There's already 400 of the 600 agencies in Missouri that are not part of FLOC. And if they're investigating a crime, they have to call us to look up data.

Speaker 1

Yeah. And I will also clarify something that was said earlier. We would not be the only entity in the six-county area that would reduce sharing. So I want to make that clear. Yeah.

Speaker 3

And, again, that's the historical way, the traditional way of law enforcement. Our file is not open across the state to anyone to search without a contact on a case.

Speaker 1

Why don't

Speaker 3

we –

Speaker 1

we haven't heard from this side of the room, and I'd love to hear what you guys have to say, so –

Speaker 6

Yes. So just to echo, um, thank you for, you know, all the residents and their feedback. I had lots of emails, lots of conversations, you know, on both sides of the spectrum. So I want you guys to all know that we really took these all into considerations and thank you for participating in this. Um, I do, I was kind of leaning. I am when we say leaning towards doing, um, the major K squad in the six counties, um, You know, it's kind of been brought up a couple of times. You know, if we look at it right now, you know, what Chief Smith showed us at our last meeting, you know, there's 58 agencies that are participating in FLOC. But as it's been brought up before, there's about 100 agency total in, you know, these six counties, which means there's 40 plus or so that are not part of FLOC. So, I mean, we do have gaping holes no matter where we are, you know, whether it's the six counties, whether it's statewide. I do think geography matters with this, especially when we go from 26,000 plus searches and it drops down to just under 9,500 searches. I do think our data is important. I know that just searching license plates, it can be said that that doesn't give you a lot of information, but it really does. It gives you, you know, you're able to track people. You're able to like see where people are going. People can create lists of people that visited certain places or, you know, houses of worship or no Kings rally, you know, things like that. There's a lot of information that's gathered. So I would like to bring it down to a more manageable, tolerable level. I do love, You know, Council Member Patel, I like the ideas of the, you know, the accreditation and the executive order having it be, you know, filing it with the state. I am concerned with the numbers because if it drops too drastically, then I do think that that's going to do no good. But I would like to see those numbers to see what that happens. I do think... And this was on my list to note that the real-time hot list, we still get those alerts so that if someone dangerous is coming into Clayton, our police will know about it, whether they are flock users or not, which I think to me is really important because we're trying to protect our residents. We want to keep our community safe. So if people are coming in, we do have access to that, whether people have access to our data or not. So I think that is something that was really important to me. Let's see. You guys took a lot of my points already. But I just want to reemphasize that I think our police have taken such a positive approach to protecting us and protecting our data. And I think we're setting a great example for this. And I am very impressed with our police. And so, and I do trust them. And I know that at the previous meeting, and I might be misquoting you, Chief Smith, that I do think he said the smallest he would prefer would be to go to six counties. I know he would probably prefer statewide, but the smallest would be that. And so that's kind of where I'm landing on this. So,

Speaker 11

yeah. I want to start by apologizing. I thought that we had been pretty clear with the police that we like really are overflowing with respect and admiration and, um, and appreciation for the collaborative nature of this whole process. And so, um, I, if that is not on the public record, like repeatedly, I want it to be there because this has been a really, for my first sort of moment of, um, contention, even within the council, um, I have been really overwhelmed by how smoothly we've been able to communicate with one another and with the police on this issue. So please make sure to put it in the notes, June. I want to probably echo some things that people have already said, because I think we have had a lot of time to process this issue. I've been on the council since May, I think was my first official meeting or April. And we've talked about it a lot since then. And so learning about this system has been an ongoing process and all of it's all of its intricacies. So I will also sort of add to my comments about the Clayton Police Department and say that Chief Smith developed a policy for our police force that I feel incredibly comfortable with the way that our police force interacts with the flock system. And I feel that when we talk about how much respect we have for our police force and the way that they are expected to use the system, that it's difficult to then allow... outside access by other agencies that aren't held to the same standard. So I think through this process of understanding the policy, understanding how the community feels about it and how the council feels about it, it's been an exercise in trying to to thread a needle that both allows our police force to effectively do their work, but also is protective of not just our community, but the people that pass through our community. And so I think I, you know, I'm, I'm pleased with where we got with this amendment. I think the, the parameters that we have sort of identified the accreditation and the certification of the government or the governor's executive order, um, don't take it as far as our own internal policy. Um, because it doesn't, the one piece that's missing there is like limiting the access of, um, the personnel within the agencies. But I'm willing to make that compromise because I think that it gets us to a better place. I do want to say again, what Councilmember Waldman said, what Mayor Patel I think said, I'm sorry, Mayor McAndrew and Councilmember Patel said about the fact that not everyone across the state of Missouri has a flock system. And we're speaking specifically about agencies that use flock. So the reality is that as it stands already, there are gaps in our visibility of um of folks moving across the state already and and we've i we got some emails that specifically called out the city of st louis which does not use uses alpr cameras but does not use flock And we engage with them quite a bit, I think, to solve crimes and return stolen cars that come from Ward 1 or across the community. So I think it just demonstrates also that there are ways to achieve the same result without unfettered access to our data. And I think the hot list is another, you know, thing that we all need to have a better understanding of, but that enables us to solve crimes without sharing data. So I'm supportive of the policy as amended. The one question that I have that we haven't talked about yet is in number two, section two about maintenance or replacement of existing cameras shall not constitute program expansion. I wonder in that if that includes software updates or like if capabilities for these cameras that we already have change based on how the software maybe changes, how are we governing that or

Speaker 8

this policy doesn't address software changes so too specifically is talking about the deployment of the physical cameras themselves right okay

Speaker 11

okay So that would be the only other thing that I would want to raise. And I don't know if it's not a deal breaker for me, but it's something for us to be thinking about, even if we keep the same infrastructure with the cameras and we're not adding anything, if the capability of the company changes and the existing cameras can be used for something else. I mean, I know the governor's executive order says no facial recognition. So I think maybe that covers it, but I just wanted to raise that. So anyway, I'm supportive of the policy as amended. And oh, the other question, I'm sorry, was about the accreditation chief that you mentioned was just for St. Louis County. So as we continue to discuss this, if we're, you know, I don't know where we are procedurally, but if we're talking about accreditation, is there something that can be, that is like the equivalent of what you were talking about for your St. Louis County chiefs that is in the rest of the other five counties?

Speaker 13

Well, so... So to be a member of the St. Louis Police Chiefs Association, you have to be accredited. But there are other agencies outside, like some of the agencies in Jefferson County, Franklin County. I don't know that we have any members from Warren County or Lincoln County. So they can still be accredited.

Speaker 11

Oh, they can still be members even if they're not just St. Louis County?

Speaker 13

That's right. Okay, thank you. Quite a bit of collaboration. Most of the St. Charles County agencies are members of the St. Louis Area Police Chiefs Association. I just think it's a geographical thing. They're not driving into our meetings from an hour away. But there are still agencies outside of that, or they have some sort of accreditation. We can look into that.

Speaker 8

Yeah, the Missouri Police Chiefs is obviously Missouri. It's statewide. And then CALEA is a national accreditation. So agencies throughout the country have that.

Speaker 11

Okay. Yeah. If it's a Missouri accreditation,

Speaker 8

yes. There are many in Missouri outside of St. Louis County that are accredited by one of those two agencies. Got it. Thank you.

Speaker 10

And you can identify that information publicly. Like it's people like advertise.

Speaker 8

Everyone that goes through the effort advertises it. Yes.

Speaker 10

Thank you.

Speaker 1

Thank you. Well, thanks for everybody's comments. I would certainly be open to the amendment as well and opening it up to our major case squad counties. But I think it's probably important at this point to hear what all of you think. So I know there weren't speaker cards out there. I do have one speaker card. It must have been the last one out there. So just a reminder that if you would like to come up and talk to us, that would be great. just state your name and your address clearly. The first person I have, and as a reminder, there will be a three-minute time limit. The first person is Hal Goldsmith. And Mr. Goldsmith, when you come up, just make sure that the green light is on at the bottom. Is it red or green? So you'll turn that... Sorry, it is kind of loud.

Speaker 12

As you said, my name is Hal Goldsmith. I'm a 30-year resident of the Hillcrest neighborhood here in Clayton. I'm also a longtime federal prosecutor here in St. Louis, and I was a state prosecutor before that. As a federal prosecutor, I see firsthand literally every day how local, state, and federal law enforcement utilize LPR data to investigate and apprehend the most violent criminals in our region to help vulnerable crime victims. Many children and youth live in my neighborhood, in Hillcrest. And if one of those high school students in my neighborhood was carjacked and the perpetrators headed east on Aberdeen or Rundle, they will pass an LPR at DeMunn and their license tag will be recorded. In five seconds, that perpetrator can be at Skinker. In 10 seconds, that perpetrater can be at I-64. And if they head east within five minutes or less, they can be in downtown St. Louis And in seven minutes, they can cross the bridge into Illinois. If they go west, they go through the western suburbs and they can go into other counties. Any number of law enforcement agencies would benefit from quick and full access to Clayton's LPR data in order to help apprehend that violent criminal. And likewise, Clayton Police would benefit from access to all of those other law enforcement agencies' LPR data. These can be life and death situations, and having quick and broad access to LPR data is a crucial tool for law enforcement. We have a terrific, experienced police chief here in Clayton. You've referred to him. He is respected throughout the entire region. He's involved in the leadership at SLAPCA as well as the region's major case squad. And while I appreciate that this council needs to exercise oversight over our police department. I also recognize that we should show substantial deference to these highly trained professionals when it comes to these types of law enforcement issues. Hopefully many of you have visited the RIC, our St. Louis County Real-Time Crime Center, and seen this technology actually in use. The work there, including the use of LPR data, helps protect Clayton residents and businesses every day. If you haven't taken the time to visit the RIC or the Clayton Police Department and see this technology firsthand, you should. It will help you understand this issue tremendously. Pictures and words only go so far. I recognize that there can be an abuse of these systems by some in law enforcement. I have prosecuted any number of police officers who have committed those types of crimes. But with the advice and experience of our police chief, the city of Clayton can put in place appropriate safeguards, allowing you appropriate oversight while still allowing the best and broadest use of this data. At a minimum, you need to think long and hard before limiting the major case squad participating counties from quick and full access to Clayton LPR data. As Becky and Betsy noted in a recent newsletter in our ward, there was a car stolen. Betsy referred to that this evening. And in their newsletter, and I quote, flock camera footage has helped investigators track the activity. The stolen vehicle was recovered in St. Louis City near Lindle and Vandiver. And that's my point exactly. Thank you all very much for your public service. It's greatly appreciated.

Speaker 1

Thank

Speaker 12

you.

Speaker 1

One at a time. Just come on up.

Speaker 14

I am Peter Smith, 23 Brighton Way. I have been amending my comments based on the contemporaneous discussion here, but I would urge the City Council to consider Alderman Gary Feder's recommendation that we remain statewide. Law enforcement agencies are increasingly working together to become more efficient and effective at preventing, investigating, and solving crimes. Sharing information across statewide jurisdictions is an important part of that effort. Clayton should not become an example of a community that unnecessarily hampers law enforcement's ability to use these tools in the interest of public safety. And I have to say, it feels kind of uncomfortable to think that we're so concerned about Clayton residents, and I'm one, and I'm concerned about us, but we're not so concerned about helping other jurisdictions solve their serious crimes. I think that's a negative place for us to be, and I think it's frankly a little shameful. We should have confidence in the professionalism and judgment of Clayton's police department leadership when they tell us that sharing this information even with just the major K squad, is important to their ability to do their jobs effectively. The Clayton Police Department's experience and operational needs deserve the most serious consideration by this council. I have to say also that I think having, I have seven young grandchildren who get dropped off at school every day, and I can't think of a better place for a camera to be than recording the cars that are dropping off or pulling up or picking up. I think we would all want to make sure that if a child were, God forbid, abducted from a school, that there's a flock camera there to capture the license plate of that offending car. I know there are concerns about potential use of license plate reader data, and we've discussed extensively the consideration for appropriate safeguards which the state and the city of Clayton have put into place. However, I think the record clearly shows that criminals targeting Clayton and other nearby residents were captured using this technology in partnership with other communities. We should not allow concerns about potential misuse to prevent our police officers from responsibly using available tools to protect our community and, importantly, assist other jurisdictions, not only in St. Louis County, not only in the major case squad counties, but across the state and the region. to use this technology to assist in solving crimes. And I will remind us that the I-70, I-170, I-55 killer, alleged killer was captured on the east side with the assistance of flock cameras. Let's make sure we keep those folks safe too. Thank you.

I am Peter Smith, 23 Brighton Way. I have been amending my comments based on the contemporaneous discussion here, but I would urge the City Council to consider Alderman Fader's recommendation that we remain statewide. Law enforcement agencies are increasingly working together to become more efficient and effective at preventing, investigating, and solving crimes. Sharing information across statewide jurisdictions is an important part of that effort. Clayton should not become an example of a community that unnecessarily hampers law enforcement's ability to use these tools in the interest of public safety. And I have to say, it feels kind of uncomfortable to think that we're so concerned about Clayton residents, and I'm one, and I'm concerned about us, but we're not so concerned about helping other jurisdictions solve their serious crimes. I think that's a negative place for us to be, and I think it's frankly a little shameful. We should have confidence in the professionalism and judgment of Clayton's police department leadership when they tell us that sharing this information even with just the major K squad, is important to their ability to do their jobs effectively. The Clayton Police Department's experience and operational needs deserve the most serious consideration by this council. I have to say also that I think having, I have seven young grandchildren who get dropped off at school every day, and I can't think of a better place for a camera to be than recording the cars that are dropping off or pulling up or picking up. I think we would all want to make sure that if a child were, God forbid, abducted from a school, that there's a flock camera there to capture the license plate of that offending car. I know there are concerns about potential use of license plate reader data, and we've discussed extensively the consideration for appropriate safeguards which the state and the city of Clayton have put into place. However, I think the record clearly shows that criminals targeting Clayton and other nearby residents were captured using this technology in partnership with other communities. We should not allow concerns about potential misuse to prevent our police officers from responsibly using available tools to protect our community and, importantly, assist other jurisdictions, not only in St. Louis County, not only in the major case squad counties, but across the state and the region. to use this technology to assist in solving crimes. And I will remind us that the I-70, I-170, I-55 killer, alleged killer was captured on the east side with the assistance of flock cameras. Let's make sure we keep those folks safe too. Thank you.

Speaker 15

Thank you for all of your time, and not only tonight, but I know you take away a lot of time from your families for the city of Clayton, so I appreciate that. I do think it's interesting that we share our addresses. My name is Charlie Brennan, 405 Carswold. Because tonight's meeting is being streamed, it'll be shown on YouTube. YouTube has 122 million daily users worldwide, no expiration date. The meeting is streamed by cameras. If I turn around, I guess you'll capture my face. You'll see my facial geometry, my name, my location is being recorded. If you're in the front rows here, your facial geometry is subject to capture. For anyone speaking, your voice print is being recorded as are some of your home addresses. So the information is actually, when you think about it, Clayton's ALPR cameras capture far less personal information than the cameras operating in this room tonight. And they make it available to a much smaller audience than 200 police departments throughout the state of Missouri. I actually think that... Flock is getting a bad rap. When you think about it, two years ago in February of 2024, Clayton officers were alerted that a stolen vehicle had passed a Flock safety license recognition camera in our jurisdiction. They located the car at Wheeler's service station on Clayton Road, confirmed the vehicle had been stolen from Merrillville, Indiana. Officers arrested the driver, James E. Ferguson of Indiana, while being fingerprinted Ferguson physically assaulted a Clayton Police Department officer. Thankfully, nobody was injured. Among the charges, sexual abuse and assault, the story received zero media attention. Nothing. However, the cases of flock data abuse in Brentwood and St. Charles, I checked out today, they were each covered by at least seven news outlets. And I think people think that the abuse is rife. In fact, it's rare by any standard. We have empirical evidence that crimes solved by ALPR far outnumber the abuses. There is just no question about that. Right now, 200 agencies in Missouri can directly access Clayton's camera data under tonight's new resolution. That number will go down to 58. That's still a 71% reduction. If we take a look at last month's figures, the searches will go from 26,000 to 9,480, and that's a 64% drop. If other departments follow our example and police can no longer directly search flock data, then police will have to communicate by phone or email. And the chief has pointed out that some investigations could slow to a crawl. So I do prefer the broadest possible ability to search. I applaud you on excluding the 287 G communities. I like the file of certification. and the accredited agencies. But I will also say, if someone in law enforcement abuses the system, I think you should put in the resolution immediate termination. I actually prefer something stronger than you have proposed. Thank you very much.

Speaker 16

Hi, Cleopatra Benos, 8019 Watkins Drive over in Davis Place.

Speaker 1

Feel free to wait until it stops. Anybody can stop. You don't have to start talking until it

Speaker 16

stops. As to the reference comment of the fact that our facial profiles and addresses will be streamed and reported, the people in this meeting have elected to be aware of that waiver of privacy by attending a public local discussion. We did not have the ability to elect or not elect into the ALPR system by simply driving through Clayton to go to work, by living in Clayton, by having children in Clayton. That is different. As to the question of whether or not this is going on YouTube, again, people choose to join a social media account and have that data impacted. That is different than having your data impacted by policies within an area. As to my statement, thank you to the council and to the Clayton Police Department for their receptiveness and communication during this process. Others have spoken today and implied that by limiting the immediate sharing to St. Louis County, that we would be limiting the ability to collaborate with other police departments. And that is simply not accurate. Clayton Police will still have access to the data and will be able to, upon request, share that data in order to solve an important crime. The aim of limiting to St. Louis County, or in this case with the amendment to the six county area, is to ensure that we're addressing the multitude of concerns regarding privacy, data retention, and other issues regarding flock. It has been mentioned that it's arbitrary or even inane to limit the sharing to St. Louis county based on a regional restriction. However, it should be equally if not more concerning for this access to have been arbitrarily extended to all of Missouri without a review on any of the people that we're sharing to. Including organizations that have a 287 G agreement. So I'm very happy to see everyone on the councils are receptive to limiting sharing to those areas that have a 28 7 G agreement. Additionally, the question is. Pretty simple. Has the Clayton Police Department and the council done an org by org review of the policies and procedures of these communities outside of St. Louis County or even within St. Louis County to ensure that their policies with regards to flock are comparable not only to the executive order, but to Clayton standards? And would they have the ability to audit those standards in an ongoing basis? As of now, that's currently no, as has been admitted by the council and the police chief. And further, without this review, it is more likely that not only is there a high chance of misuse, but there's an extremely high chance that we wouldn't even be able to catch the misuse because we wouldn't know how to track and find it. As the police chief has attested, his staff understandably currently doesn't have the capacity to truly review the 20,000 plus shares of our data currently, which means that we don't have the capacity, to genuinely ensure the privacy of people living in Clayton or passing through Clayton. I strongly urge us to continue the proposed idea to limit to St. Louis County. If needed, though, I would understand the limiting to the six-unit major case squad for good faith collaboration.

Speaker 1

Thank you. Thank you. I think you're up, Nancy.

Speaker 17

Okay. Well, a lot of my comments have been discussed by all of you. Thank you. I know it's taken a lot of time. I do commend you on the 287G exclusion. I think that a lot of the other standards are great. Everybody's talked about geographic. You've gotten, hopefully read my email. I do want to bring back the comment about the timeline. I understand the seven days is why you might want to have that for the restriction. But once that data is deleted, it's gone. 30 days is the Missouri standard. I think that If you're really against the full 30 days, consider archiving it after seven days. But I would urge you to reconsider that because once that data is deleted, it's gone. And a lot of crimes aren't even reported for seven days. The police chief can speak to this more accurately than I can, but that's really, I just wanted to add that comment. Okay. Thank you.

Speaker 1

Thank you, Nancy.

Speaker 18

My name is Rick Weber. I live at 601 East Polo. Just a couple of things because I submitted, as you know, a written statement yesterday to the council. First of all, I think I need to apologize. I was the person who said that it was, I use the term nonsensical to not include the city of St. Louis within the bounds of what was proposed by the council. Nonsensical is a word I love to use in legal briefs in previous times. So anyway, that's probably too strong. I'm sorry. So, as I listened to this today. What I am beginning to hear is that instead of a limitation to St Louis County. We're moving toward a limitation to this 6 county major case. Squad counties, I guess. And I just think that's a false compromise. Maybe six counties are better than just St. Louis County, but if six counties are better then 10 counties are better than six counties and 50 counties are better than 10 counties. And I think it's a false compromise, we have to get back to considering how significant this risk is And I think it's not very significant. We read about these things, very individual things where some police officer went rogue. But really, it's not a great risk. And I don't think the risk is changed very much when we're talking about the statewide solution instead of a six-county solution. So I urge everyone not to just fall into the six-county thinking well that that sounds like a nice compromise we're all going to be safe with six counties and the other thing is the gentleman pointed out earlier that it still raises the question of cooperation if others perceive us as only being willing to share with six counties uh and they're not one of those six counties uh they're not going to be happy with that and that might cause us not to get the cooperation we'd like to get from those other counties. So thank you very much.

Speaker 1

Thank you. Maybe I'll take this moment to see if there's anybody online that would like to speak. If so, feel free to raise your hand either now or soon if you're interested in speaking. Is there anybody else in the audience that would like to

Speaker 19

my name is beth store and i live at 405 carswold i want to thank you all for listening to folks i don't think that this issue around flock data sharing was on the radar of many of your constituents despite the fact that you have talked about it at several meetings so i think it was important that outreach be made to folks and discussions be made, because I think this is a very important decision. I'm very glad that you aren't blocking direct access to 71% of the agencies who use the data today. I know many of you have concerns about data privacy, leaning more to that, I think, than to the success of Flock. And the flock, I'd say flock data privacy is important to Claytonians but not as important as public safety. Perhaps with the exception of the 287G. Claytonians are concerned about public safety both in Clayton and in our region because as the region goes so does Clayton period. I would like to ask you all to even slow down a little bit. I think it's important because of the changes that have been made recently at the state of Missouri by FLOC and by other law agencies that we actually take a six-month reprieve. and that we allow data to be shared with the entire state of Missouri, with the exception of 287G. And I believe strongly that that exception, that data shouldn't be shared with those agencies. I think it's important, as you talked about tonight, to give those other agencies time to get accredited, time to come up to speed on their own procedures and policies before blocking our access. I do think it is important to note that others will follow our practice. Clayton is a leader, which is why it really is important that Clayton consider how its policy decisions affect the public safety beyond our municipal borders. I think we could be starting a domino effect, which would be negative, which I think that waiting six months in order to do anything beyond 287G would be prudent. I think the gaping holes that you all talked about tonight in the system make using flock to its maximum level more important than ever. Thank you.

Speaker 1

Thank you.

Speaker 20

Ryan Hoffman, 48 Arundel Place. Look, I think everyone recognizes the utility of ALPR cameras and their effective support for law enforcement. We're talking about an extremely powerful revolutionary technology at a scale humanity has never seen before. I appreciate the tension between privacy and protection And with anything this big, I think it's important to take a step back and acknowledge this is really hard work. So thank you. Thank you, Mayor McAndrew, members of the City Council, and Chief Smith for your time and your partnership to discuss this matter. My wife, three kids, and border collie, we all live on the corner of Arundel and Daman and Hillcrest. We moved to the neighborhood in February 2022 and feel like we won the lottery. We walk our kids to school along with 100 other kids and parents. I take our two youngest up the hill to regularly play at Daman Playground and to buy treats from Katie at the candy shop. I share these snapshots because while independent from one another, they may not be much, but stitched together, they reveal a life. Unlike Google Street View, Flock does not automatically blur the faces of passing pedestrians, children, passengers, or bystanders caught in the background of a vehicle snapshot. This means innocent residents walking their dogs, pushing strollers or standing on sidewalks are passively cataloged and unblurred searchable database. I'm here to share my serious concerns with Flock and our city's contribution to an unregulated nationwide surveillance system. While we the city of Clayton are the data owners, Flock is the data processors extracting the broadest amount of our citizens movements as they fuel their AI data machine and develop ever-increasing data surveillance equipment. What started as a single ALPR to deter and track car break-ins nine years ago has become a $7.5 billion behemoth after a $150 million investment from one of the largest VC firms in Silicon Valley. In the process, their primary customers shifted from HOAs and private businesses to governments. Their business model shifted from a hardware leasing program to an AI-powered safety as a service. And in just nine years, Flock has connected footage from over 120,000 ALPRs spanning more than 6,000 communities across 49 states, forming a first-of-its-kind national camera network. We've allowed a private company unaccountable to its customers and local jurisdictions to be above the law and create a tool Congress would have never even allowed itself to create. I urge the city council to not adopt any additional flock cameras and to consider like 200 other cities across the country canceling our contract until the law catches up to this technology. If the city is unwilling to do this, I recommend the following proposals in addition to Chief Smith's policies and Governor Kehoe's executive order, starting with these nine. Number one, require judicial warrant or formal reasonable suspicion. Two, explicitly ban the use of this network for non-criminal administrative tracking. Three, prohibit regional and out-of-state data pooling. Four, enact location-based density restrictions. Five, enact crime-specific time boundaries. Six, mandate automatic privacy blurring. Seven, establish a police tech and compliance unit. Eight, establish an independent civilian-led data governance board. Nine, reduce data retention period 24 to 48 hours. Flock is attempting to bring the same level of surveillance to the offline world that already exists online. Our children deserve the reasonable expectation of privacy that we all grew up with, that they can be who they are and become who they will without being passively filmed. Thank you very much for your time. Thank

Speaker 1

you. Anyone else?

Speaker 21

My name is Natalie Dowd, and I live in Ward 2. I'm concerned about a shift in the conversation that has brought in a piece of misinformation that has continuously been repeated here, and that is that these cameras only track license plates That is not correct, and we've discussed this previously. They also create an entire fingerprint of every vehicle that passes in their view. It includes the license plate number. It includes damage to the car. It includes roof racks. It includes tow hitches. It includes bumper stickers, which can be read by the AI. I just want to keep that in mind. It is not just following license plates, and it is searchable by all those other items as well. In addition to that, there's a piece of misleading information going on here, which is that if we exclude 287 agreement cities, that we are excluding ICE entirely. That's simply not the case. There are plenty of police departments that openly work with ICE but have not actually gone through the 287 process, which involves additional training and other sorts of procedural steps. And they may not be interested in doing that contract process, yet still they work with ICE, share information, and do not necessarily have any restrictions on sharing information. Can you put the clock where I can see it? So yeah, so that's also false. So when we restrict places that don't have a 287 , we are still restricting ICE actually because there is lots of open sharing there. That's not under contract. In a previous comment that I made, I gave an example of a police chief in Brazelton, Georgia, who accessed flock data from Capitola, California to stalk and harass unnamed victims. I'd like to go back to that one for a minute because at the time, I wanted to give more information on the relationship to the unnamed victims for context, and I couldn't find any. The reason for that is one of the victims was a minor child. Stalk and harass a 16-year-old, a police chief. That police chief is now in prison. So as you consider how much to restrict, please consider 16 and 17-year-olds. How many hundreds or thousands of grown men do you want to have access to the whereabouts and habits of our teenage girls? Please respect and protect girls and women. Thank you. Thank

Speaker 1

you. there anyone else in the audience that would like to speak anyone else anyone else online all right thank you oh i'm sorry

Speaker 22

Hi, I'm Rosie Lang, Ward 2 resident on and off, or Ward 1 resident on and off for over 20 years. Thank you so much to the City Council for these really robust conversations. I've really been grappling with this idea that in order to have safety, we have to give up privacy because I do think this day and age, privacy is a safety issue. You know, AI technology is moving really fast. Blocks of private corporation are There have been a lot of cases of misidentification with these systems, and it has been misused. So, you know, sometimes I hear if you're not doing anything wrong, you have nothing to worry about. But I think we're really well past that with how fast the technology is moving. I did have an area of clarification that I'm seeking because we're talking about limits to 287 agreements, but also sharing with the major case squad, the six counties in Missouri. And so I'm wondering about any overlap that might exist, and if that is the case, like with some of the sheriff's departments in the greater region, what would take precedence in terms of sharing?

Speaker 1

We would not. I mean, the policy would be even if you're part of the six counties, we would not share with you if you have a 287G agreement.

Speaker 22

Okay. Thank you. Um, because I mean, I don't want my car stolen as much as the next person or my neighbor's car stolen. Um, but I really don't want the fear of that to supersede the safety of others or other types of safety as well. Right. I don't want to be the reason for someone else to be unsafe, whether that's our immigrant neighbors or those who visit or work in Clayton and hearing about the very well publicized case in Brentwood, I found myself asking. Was Clayton data used in that? Did the victim travel through our area and was tracked through it? I know I don't feel good about that possibility. I'm also reminded that these ALPRs are only one tool in the kit, so to speak. Our police department, it seems, has had really strong collaboration and relationship building via multiple methods and partnerships over the years regionally. And that shouldn't be discounted. I have no doubt that it'll continue. When talking with other parents or neighbors, I find the conversation returning to the same questions. Safe for who and at what cost? Which I think has come up here before. Safe for who is an equity question and at what cost is an ethical one? So my family actually supports canceling the contract, but in lieu of that, at a minimum, making some very common sense restrictions to data sharing that was discussed here tonight. Thank you so much. Thank you.

Speaker 1

Mr. Uchitel, you can speak when you're ready.

Speaker 23

Thank you very much. Just a very thoughtful conversation back and forth. I'd like to hear more about how the chief excludes 287C jurisdictions when one of the cars that they're looking for passes through that area. Thank you.

Speaker 17

Is there still one?

Speaker 13

To answer that question, in the program, it lists all the agencies we share with. You essentially just click on that agency and we can uncheck the box for sharing with them. It's that easy.

Speaker 1

And then, I mean, but if they had a crime problem, they would just then have to reach out to us. Sure. I mean, really, there would be any number of ways that we would be alerted to a problem, but they could always, obviously, you would collaborate with them in other ways. That's

Speaker 13

for that case-by-case simulations in there. They could reach out to us and they could tell us, hey, we're investigating a robbery, and we would help them.

Speaker 1

Right. Thank you. I don't see any other hands up online. Anybody else in the audience? Okay, great. Thank you very much, everybody. I think all of us have said we just sincerely appreciate everybody's comments, all the emails. You know, we're lucky in Clayton. We have a wonderful group of residents who are very engaged and thoughtful. So certainly sincerely appreciate all the thought that everybody has in emails and just everybody that has talked to us about this issue. Mr. Jeffery Yorg, I know you had to leave us briefly. I will, I think maybe we need to reframe the discussion back on the amendment that Council Member Patel has suggested, which would include adding, sure, that'd be great. That'd be great. Yes, thank

Right. Thank you. I don't see any other hands up online. Anybody else in the audience? Okay, great. Thank you very much, everybody. I think all of us have said we just sincerely appreciate everybody's comments, all the emails. You know, we're lucky in Clayton. We have a wonderful group of residents who are very engaged and thoughtful. So certainly sincerely appreciate all the thought that everybody has in emails and just everybody that has talked to us about this issue. Mr. York, I know you had to leave us briefly. I will, I think maybe we need to reframe the discussion back on the amendment that Council Member Patel has suggested, which would include adding, sure, that'd be great. That'd be great. Yes, thank

Speaker 8

you. Actually read in here. So if amended per Council Member Patel's suggestion under number four, which is interagency data sharing, under the heading automatic access. It would read automatic access to the city's ALPR system shall be limited to eligible law enforcement agencies located within the Missouri counties participating in the major case squad of Greater St. Louis, accredited by the Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies or the Missouri Police Chiefs Association, and that have submitted an executive order 2618 compliance certification form to the Missouri Department of Public Safety. Those are the changes that were suggested. We preserved the language relative to 287G agencies being ineligible.

Speaker 10

I believe that actually accurately captures my intent. Thank

Speaker 3

you. Does any go ahead? Yeah, I have a question. So if the executive order is a 30 day retention limit, is that right? How does that work with our seven day?

Speaker 13

Maximum 30 days. So we went below that to seven days.

Speaker 3

Right. But if somebody with whom we decide to share has a 30 day, we have a seven. Does that mean they can't search? We deleted it at seven days. We only have seven

Speaker 13

days of data available to ourselves and everybody else.

Speaker 3

So if they search it on day six, is that downloaded information they have or how do they... How does that interact? I

Speaker 13

mean, if they search on day six, it's still available. If they search eight days prior, it's gone. It's deleted, yeah.

Speaker 3

But if they searched on day six, do they retain it in their system then or it's just gone?

Speaker 13

They could retain it. If there was data they found useful, they could retain it. But part of the executive order, I believe, says you're not supposed to retain any data that's not a part of investigation.

Speaker 11

But do you get – like if I searched – This feels rudimentary. If I searched for a license plate and there was nothing in Clayton that applied to that search, it would not return any information.

Speaker 13

That's a good question. So if Richmond Heights searches for 123XYZ and it doesn't come through Clayton, they're not going to get anything from us. Right.

Speaker 11

So it's not like they're saying, I want to search on September 4th. But if they said, I want to enclave, then presumably any number of white Buick enclaves would return a result.

Speaker 13

That's correct.

Speaker 11

Yeah.

Speaker 13

But like most searches, like I gave you examples of how we did, you know, did the search for the homicide. Most searches have a parameter of a date and time. You know, it wouldn't be practical to find every Buick enclave for seven days. You know when the crime occurred and you're looking at specific location and time period.

Speaker 3

I have one more question. Yeah, go ahead. I'm very concerned with expanding any of this, but I was curious. Mr. Hoffman gave a list of things to consider, which I couldn't quite follow how fast you went. And with the comment, too, that the technology is going forward very fast and it's hard to play catch up. So if we were to adopt this policy tonight, this is a fluid... What's the word? It's a very fluid thing. The use of it that you used it for and as the technology changes and everything else, I'm looking at this as something that we will revisit in a timely manner. I don't know what that means or what people want with that, but we can always consider putting in more or less or something else as we see how things are actually playing out and the real experience.

Speaker 13

I agree, and I will be informing you of our use of LPR data every quarter based off this policy, and that would be a good time to readdress issues.

Speaker 3

Okay, and the other thought I had, I noticed that too, and I love the proposed policy, that there may be consequences if somebody abuses the policy. Is that something that the council would consider making stricter? Or would you word it differently? It's worded so generally you can't tighten it up because you don't know what the violation might have been.

Speaker 8

My only concern would be... if we tighten that up, possibly not being compliant with our collective bargaining agreement.

Speaker 23

Okay.

Speaker 8

Because it addresses discipline there. So we have to fall under our current general orders. So if we were to say automatic termination or something like that, I think that would run afoul of our collective bargaining agreement

Speaker 3

process. And

Speaker 8

I do

Speaker 3

have to say that because of, as has been mentioned, the trust we have in you and the quality of the department, that it doesn't concern me that much, that it's this lose at this stage? If

Speaker 13

there's abuse, I assure you we'll seek the

Speaker 3

trick. Yeah, yeah. There's accountability.

Speaker 8

The other thing I would point out as far as the ability to amend this, and we understand this technology is changing, that's why we want to do this the way we are, which is a policy attached to a resolution. So that if at any point the council wants to make amendments or modifications to it, it's rather easy to do with a resolution. We can bring the policy back and you can adopt changes at any time. resolution isn't you know it's a policy we're going to abide by um it's a policy that you've set forth but it's it's not you know an ordinance that's a little more tedious to change those laws over and over again

Speaker 1

yep thank you councilman Jeffery Yorg there's no pressure but if do you want to make any comments or

yep thank you councilman york there's no pressure but if do you want to make any comments or

Speaker 5

Yeah. So a couple of things. So thank you all for coming. And I apologize. I had a previous family thing, so I was kind of out and then back. A couple of things besides that, I would say, and a lot of you acknowledge this, but as someone who's sat on different nonprofits and corporate stuff over the years, I will say that when you look at I will give all seven of us credit and you all should know the amount of hours that all of us spent thinking about this. Like it's very clear as you could probably see from, obviously I missed the discussion earlier, but there was a lot that we all went into. We may not all wind up in the same spot, but you should know that there's very few things I've been involved with where you have this many people thinking about it. So hopefully that should give you all comfort in some regard that you've got folks who really care about what this is and they're trying to weigh every email we get and every call we get and every thought that you all, um, provide on all sides. Um, I mean, like I said, a couple of weeks ago, you know, I think of this very much as kind of a teeter totter to put it in old kid phrase, which is how do you try to balance the privacy of one versus the security of another? And there's clearly a lot of nuances we've all covered. And, um, you know, Generally speaking, I think what sounds like the compromise that everybody kind of or the amendment that people talked about makes sense from a balancing the idea of safety with the idea of privacy and kind of what's the risk-reward of it all. And I know all of us in the room will probably slightly differ as to how we balance that. But I will say for me, I've tried to do my best to figure out what that teeter-totter scale is. And this makes more sense to me than... the way the amendment was originally drafted. What I will say, though, and this may be better saved for after we deal with the amendment, but since I've got the floor, I might as well say it now. I do think, though, that with the changes that are being proposed, I see it as a fundamental enough change in the resolution that was published for the public that it's not something that I would want to vote on tonight. The amendment I'm okay with, but in terms of the actual resolution, it's such an important thing. There's so many diversity of people's opinion on it. I feel like going from just St. Louis County to the region and adding these other ones while I support the change, I feel like the people should have more time to provide input to the pretty significant changes to the resolution that was put out there. So that was all I got. So thank you, Mayor.

Speaker 10

Thank you. Shall I officially make the motion to amend? I think that would be read. Sure, go ahead. Yes, I move to amend this resolution as read by our city manager.

Speaker 1

Second. Is there any further discussion from the council about this, about the motion to amend?

Speaker 4

Well, I have a comment. You know, two weeks ago when it appeared the majority wanted to have a one state, one county only approach to this. I guess, frankly, if the next day somebody had said you can go to six counties, I would have said, well, for compromise purposes, that's a hell of a big leap and the problem is that everyone I have heard from, and because I think I expressed a lot of this at the last meeting, maybe I'm getting more emails on this than other people, but I literally think I've gotten at least three dozen emails from people. And the consistent message is we believe in chief Smith and our police department. We don't want to tie literally his hands behind his back, um, And what we're doing tonight is exactly that. There's no doubt that Chief Smith is supportive of the statewide system. He's trying to be cooperative in saying of these three alternatives, this one, six counties is the best. And I guess it is. Maybe it's the least bad. But the fact is, you know, I hear we can revisit it. Once we go from a statewide system to six counties, I think we'd be the first in the system statewide.

Speaker 1

We're not. We are not. We are misinformed. We are not We are not. There's an agency in St. Charles County that already only shares with the major case squad.

Speaker 4

Okay, well, good. We're only the second one in the state to have done it.

Speaker 1

I haven't investigated every, but on the ones that search our system commonly, we are not the only ones. Major case squad or mutual aid? Major case squad. Okay. Yeah.

Speaker 4

In any event, my point is that I think we can we can now share with them the role of being of a promoting exclusion instead of inclusion. And I don't really think that's where we want to be. I don't think we should tell our police chief as the council what is the best method. And the message I got, like I said, universally from people I heard from is don't undermine inclusion. Here's the system. We want to feel safe. We've done lots and lots of stuff for data protection. We ought to think about what it does to our system, and if this month we cut off 114 counties who have had access, we do have to think about what's going to happen in the rest of the state. Will they choose to do the same thing? I think that's a serious problem, and I don't think one... that I could be comfortable with. So I'm comfortable with the 287 exclusion. I'm comfortable with criteria, the accreditation and the affidavit. I am not comfortable with the geographic decision. We praise the chief at every opportunity and tonight we're taking a measure that is not what he recommends and I think hurts the safety of our citizens.

Speaker 1

Okay. So, but based on the motion to amend, um, is there any other comments on the motion to amendment? Otherwise we can vote on the, that there is a motion in a second. Um, so the motion, we all know what the amendments are, so all those in favor. I.

Speaker 11

Wait, sorry. We're voting on

Speaker 1

the amendment, not the actual. No, the policy will come next. So the amend. So the so. Yes. Opposed.

Speaker 4

Are we do I just want to say we're just just on the train to make an amendment, not what the amendment says is that

Speaker 1

the substantive part of the amendment?

Speaker 4

Yes. Then a very emphatic no. Thank you

Speaker 1

for you. I'm fine. Okay. Okay. So the amendment passes. And if there's any further discussion on the policy itself?

Speaker 10

I just want to say a few things. So I knew about the use of ALPRs in Clayton from the beginning because I am a resident of Hillcrest and I lived there, I have lived there since before the time that the Hillcrest neighborhood partnered with the Clayton Police Department to put the cameras in. I knew about them. I wasn't particularly concerned. I didn't see it as something to be concerned about. Honestly, there was this big, there was a lot of fear in our neighborhood because of the auto thefts and some other significant crime that had occurred. That was unusual for our experience and people wanted to close our gates. And I'm like, really don't want to live in a gated community. So I was thrilled that we came up with something that made our neighbors feel safe that didn't involve that. and that was years ago and then um as i've been on the city council we've heard many successes of the system how it has helped um our department and our to work with our neighbors to solve some crimes it's been one of the tools in their investigative toolkit. It's never the only one. And then a year and a half ago, I went to a national conference of local elected officials. And that's where I started to learn about the misuse and abuse of these ALPR systems. And I want to be clear that misuse of these systems is not a potentiality. It is a reality. Any system that has data in it that human beings are involved in has the potential for risk. And there are best practices that people and organizations can implement to try to mitigate that risk. But the risk is real. An innocent woman spent 13 days in jail, including solitary confinement because she was misidentified by a flock camera. People have had guns pulled on them when they've been pulled over and they were misidentified. It doesn't always get the plates right. There are 50 documented cases of stalking and harassment overwhelmingly of women. And so I think it is really important to remember that safety is provided and crime is prevented through a whole variety of delivery mechanisms. And surveillance does not equal safety. And it is important for us to think about too, as Rosie said, who is this safe for? And so I feel comfortable with what we're moving forward with tonight And I view it as like our next step in this process. Um, when I first learned about the misuses and abuses of the system, chief Smith met with me as soon as I asked him about it. And he showed me how the system work and he demystified it and answered my questions. And we continued to be in discussion about it. And in the spring, we had an in-depth discussion at our city council retreat, um, And after that discussion, the chief developed a policy, which I think is truly like a model policy. He developed the policy. We didn't tell him exactly what to do. He responded to the concerns we raised and the needs of his department and what he knows about the system and best practices because he's an amazing police chief of a CALEA-certified accredited organization, right? And so... where we are now. And since then, Gary, we have heard from many residents who have taken the time to come to our public meetings and talk about some of their concerns about these systems and the way they can be abused. This is not, we are not getting uniform feedback from our residents. And so I believe that where we are right now is that I support implementing the policy as amended. And I think it's really important for us to continue to monitor, to listen to the police department. The chief is going to report to us quarterly. If something big happens, we can request a report at another time. We can do that. And that we will continue, I believe myself and some of my colleagues will continue to engage with other communities and elected officials. We've had elected officials from neighboring communities following our discussion and asking questions and talking to us like they're trying to figure out what to do here too. And I think we'll also be engaging with the state. I know we have connections in Jeff City who will be reporting for duty in January, and we can advocate and listen and share with them as they consider whether to draft statewide policy. I just wanted to say that because I don't think we've actually maybe heard enough about the actual innocent people who have been harmed by this system. So thank you.

Speaker 4

May I just say that I have never heard a vote taken on a matter that was debated, and then we had after the fact a speech to justify it.

Speaker 1

Gary, we're getting

Speaker 4

ready to vote

Speaker 1

on the policy. We haven't voted on the policy yet. We're not going to engage in that. I would like to say – I would also like to say that I have gotten – I have certainly gotten emails and comments across the spectrum. So I have gotten, certainly also gotten a very mixed reaction. And I think as Council Member Patel has mentioned, I think this is a great first step. There is a risk to sharing this data with agencies across the state. This is a important first step, and why wouldn't we require an agency that we're sharing this data with? Why wouldn't we require what the governor required? That to me is a really important first step. But I would also like, and as has already been mentioned, this is very much an evolving issue. I have heard from multiple people that this is something that legislators in Jefferson City are concerned about. who knows what will happen with that you never know what's going to happen in jefferson city but i know that they're keeping an eye on things so i i want to thank you all again for engaging with us um and i especially want to thank chief smith um he has been a super leader throughout all this chief thank you very much for your leadership in this leadership in the region um i just i we sincerely appreciate it your community sincerely appreciates it so So we have voted on the amendment. If there's no further discussion, council member abuse. Okay.

Speaker 3

I move to approve resolution number 2026-34 as amended, adopting the automated license plate recognition policy.

Speaker 1

Second. Second. Is there any further discussion? All those in favor?

Speaker 5

Hold on. I was still going to raise the point that I raised earlier where... Oh,

Speaker 1

delaying it?

Speaker 5

Delaying it. There

Speaker 1

is only... Yeah, because there is only one vote. I would like to move forward with it tonight. And if I...

Speaker 5

There's a motion on the floor, so we need to. But that was the comment I was going to make before we started voting. So...

Speaker 4

I would support Jeff's motion. I would not normally because I'd not like to see this drag on for another three weeks, but I think there's been some suggestion here that there's vast parts of the community who think that what I had suggested, which is this undermining of our police department, is not the only point of view. And I grant that it isn't the only point of you, but This is an important issue. And I think, frankly, if you went through the community and asked them what they thought about this decision tonight of going from statewide to these six counties, they would feel that it is not in their best interest. And frankly, I'd like to know what they think, since my opinion apparently doesn't seem to weigh too much with my colleague's.

Speaker 1

Um, so Jeff, so there is an outstanding motion. So, um, like a motion to table this for some,

Speaker 10

no, we have to,

Speaker 1

we get to vote on the resolution. All those in favor. Aye. Any opposed?

Speaker 5

Opposed. I'm abstaining.

Speaker 1

That takes care of that.

Speaker 10

The motion carries.

Speaker 1

So the motion carries, I guess, five to one to one. Five to one. All right. Thank you all of you that we have come to the end of our agenda. There was. I will, if there's nothing else, would somebody like to make a motion to adjourn? Yeah.

Speaker 5

Motion to adjourn. Sorry, Susan.

Speaker 1

Second. All those in favor? Aye. Thank you.