The neighbors to the west of the people that asked for the variance spoke at the meeting, but they're not noted here in the minutes. Is that supposed to be included? We can update the minutes to know that there was public comment. Okay. I would also note that in the first paragraph under the minutes that Bryce Woollen's name is misspelled. Any other comments or concerns? If not, I'll entertain a motion to approve. How about make the motion? I move to approve the minutes. there's a second all in favor aye aye no opposed okay we'll move on uh tonight we have one application on the agenda which is an appeal from randy lipton who is the applicant for the property located at 224 and 228 beamiston avenue mr lipton are you ready okay now before we go further Anyone wishing to speak either in favor or in opposition to the application needs to be sworn in. If you would, please stand up. Rebecca will swear you in. If anybody wants to make any comment at any point, we'd ask that you get sworn in now. You can both stand at the same time. Just stay right there. Yeah. If you're going to speak, raise your right hand, please. Please tell them we swear a testimony and vow to give the truth to hold you. Please help me God. Okay. Well, first let's start Mr. City Attorney. Does the city have any exhibits to be offered for consideration? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair.